Showing posts with label Julian Fantino. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Julian Fantino. Show all posts

Friday, April 06, 2012

Why is Julian Fantino hiding his campaign donors?

Blogger The Sixth Estate has written a post drawing attention to the campaign finance filing of Vaughan Conservative MP Julian Fantino from last year's election, noting two campaign contributions of "Dinner" and "Donation" that are rather odd names you don't hear every day. And if they are names, at $117,600 and $65,585 respectively they're well over the individual contribution limit of $1100 for donations to a political campaign.
Now, oddly enough, the Fantino campaign didn’t report a postal code either for Mr. Dinner, or for Mr. Donation. I wonder why that could be. As you can see, Mr. Donation is a very wealthy person. The legal limit is well short of $65,585, but that didn’t stop him! And who paid for the dinner? I certainly hope Elections Canada has more information than we do.
Intrigued, I went over to the Elections Canada web site to take a look for myself. And I was surprised to see that under "Candidates' Details - Statement of Contributions Received (Part 2a)" the only two donations listed were, indeed, Dinner and Donations.

To say this isn't how you are supposed to complete a filing is an understatement. Donations by corporations and unions are banned, and every donation by an individual over $20 must be identified by name and the amount of each contribution. Yet the Fantino campaign filing doesn't list the name of one single campaign contributor.

It would seem likely that the Fantino campaign held a major fundraising dinner that raised $117,600, and also raised another $65,585 through donations. Yet, for some reason, they listed the totals by categories instead of the names of individual contributors and the amount each donated, as required by law. It's such a ridiculous thing to do I'm inclined to think it was sheer incompetence rather than malice, as it's not the sort of thing you could expect to slip under the radar. One look at the filing and it's glaringly obvious. And if it is malicious, at best they could hope to delay the revelation of the names of their donors by a year.

The data posted in Fantino's filing is "as submitted" and hasn't been approved by Elections Canada. It's likely that someone from Elections Canada will be in contact with Fantino's official agent, looking for the missing information. Failure to comply would seem to, at a minimum, mean no expense rebate for the campaign (a loss of tens of thousands of dollars). Fines and possible de-registration of the riding association may also be possibilities; I'm not an expert on the intricacies of election law.

In the meantime, the question remains, just who donated to Fantino's campaign and why hasn't he revealed the list of donors, as required? It it just sheer incompetence or does he have something to hide?

It bears noting, though, that while an argument of sheer incompetence is reasonable with this incident in isolation, make questions have been swirling around the Fantino campaign of late:

* Ex-Tory riding execs question Fantino's election finances

Three former members of the Conservative riding association in Vaughan, Ont., are asking Elections Canada to investigate the campaign's finances. In sworn affidavits, Richard Lorello, Tracey Kent and Carrie Liddy allege possible irregularities in Julian Fantino's 2010 byelection and 2011 election campaigns.

* Elections Canada urged to investigate Fantino

The three former riding association members allege that Fantino’s fundraising chair, Sam Ciccolini, said at a January 2011 meeting that there was a second bank account belonging to the campaign that contained more than $300,000. It is against election rules to have more than one campaign bank account.


Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Monday, January 03, 2011

Julian Fantino doubles-down on Liberals=Nazis

It's really a shame, although completely understandable, that Conservative HQ kept Julian Fantino away from the media with a pitchfork during the Vaughan by-election. Because every time this guy opens his mouth in front of a reporter, the results never fail to be entertaining.


Take these comments by Fantino shortly after last November's by-election win, where he proceeds to play the sore winner with aplomb:
"I think they [the Liberals] intended to hurt my campaign. The things they said ... a lot of them were absolute lies. They keep repeating [them]. I call it the Hitler Theory. You tell a lie often enough you hope that some people will believe it."
His whiny tone expressing surprise his opponents wouldn't just step aside, recognize his obvious awesomeness and concede to a coronation aside, Fantino pathetically smearing his opponents with the Nazi card speaks to an intellectual vapidness that makes obvious why he ran away from all candidates debates left, right and centre.

Obviously, the Liberals called on Fantino to apologize and/or Harper to take him aside and tell him to smarten-up. Obviously, the call went unheeded and last week, in an interview with his local paper.

Fantino made clear that not only wouldn't he apologize for comparing the Liberals to Nazis, but that they should apologize to him. I guess, for acting like Nazis or something.
Shortly after the Nov. 25 byelection, Fantino drew fire when he drew comparisons between the campaign and Hitler, a comment he says was taken out of context.

“A lot of this is show business and taking things out of context,”Fantino said. “What I did … refer to a process that I experienced and not cast aspersion on any particular person.

“That whole passage of history is unpleasant. And some of the things that happened to me on my campaign were unpleasant too.”

Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff called on Fantino to apologize.

“Mr. Ignatieff can stand on his soapbox all he wants: I am not making any apologies,” Fantino said. “I feel like I was the victim and he should be apologizing to me.”
First of all, Julian, would you care to explain exactly what the context was that would make your comparison of the Liberals to Nazis something other than asinine? Because I'm not seeing it.

So you weren't comparing one specific Liberal to Nazis, just all of them?

Or they're not Nazis, they just act like Nazis?

Keep digging, Julian. Keep digging.

I do see the hilarity in your complaining about personal attacks, comparing your opponents to Nazis, and then demanding they apologize for being Nazi meanies.

I always figured Fantino was a bully, but I am surprised by his utter inability to take a punch. And for someone who supposedly hates personal attacks, I look forward to the first time the teenagers in the PMO give him a member's statement attack script to read in the House, or he takes a look at his party's advertising, talking points, and entire modus operandi.

Some advice: Be careful who you compare your own party to, Julian.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Byelections 2010: No trends, just some stuff that happened

After every by-election, it’s always fun to watch the punditry and chattering classes flail about trying to read the entrails in search of trends to derive from the results. Politicos will look for trends to favour their party, while pundits will look for trends they can shoe-horn into whatever narrative they’ve been pushing, thereby affirming their awesome powers of punditness.


While every now and again you can find national trends in by-election results (there is an exception to every rule, after all) by and large there are usually no wider trends to derive from a series of randomly occurring by-elections scattered around the country. Usually, they’re just some stuff that happened, driven by unique circumstances in each riding.

Thomas Mulcair’s byelection win in Outremont didn’t presage an NDP wave sweeping Quebec. Elizabeth May’s strong second-place showing in London North Centre didn’t presage a Green wave, or get May any closer to the House of Commons.

The same is true for last night’s three races. Local factors are behind each result, and those trying to read too much into them are only fooling themselves. Or trying to fool us, because I’m sure most of them probably don’t believe the malarkey they’re peddling anyways.

The Races

Let’s start with the easiest one: Dauphin-Swan River-Marquette. It’s a strong Conservative riding in the rural West that stayed a strong Conservative riding last night. No change, no trend, status quo.

Further south was Winnipeg North. In a tight two-way race in a traditionally NDP seat (although Ray Pagtakhan snuck in there for a bit for the Liberals), Liberal Kevin Lamourex narrowly defeated NDP candidate Kevin Chief.

Is this a sign of a red wave set to sweet the prairie West? Is the NDP vote about to collapse? Not hardly. This was a case of a strong and respected but new to politics candidate in Chief facing off against a veteran of provincial politics in Lamoureux. Both sides poured-in resources and volunteers and fought hard on the ground, but in the end Lamoureux’s name-recognition was likely the difference. Hard to find any trends there.

And then there’s Vaughan. A Liberal seat for some years, by narrow margins at first and then with increasing pluralities. Often Conservative provincially, and in a belt of 905 seats that tend to tip bluish.

Expected to be a landslide for high-profile star Conservative candidate Julian Fantino over last-minute Liberal candidate Tony Genco, it ended up being a very narrow Conservative victory.

As the marquee match-up in the eyes of the media punditry, everyone is quick to ascribe trends to this result. Some say it’s a sign of a coming Conservative breakthrough in the GTA. Of course, that requires overlooking that the Conservatives already hold the ridings to the North (Oak Ridges-Markham), West (Dufferin-Caldeon) and South-East (Thornhill). Others say it was a referendum on Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff, and he failed (no races being referendums on anyone else, of course).

In actuality, the result in Vaughan can entirely be attributed to local factors, national trends be dammed.

It was a seat with favourable demographics for a Conservative candidate, held in recent years in part by the personal popularity of the Liberal incumbent, recently elected to the mayoralty in a landslide. A Conservative star candidate with extremely high name recognition (and a nearly guaranteed cabinet post) faced off against a Liberal neophyte, and was expected to win handily. Instead, he eked-out a narrow victory. It’s hardly a surprising result, and it’s not indicative of any wider trend. The race was tight, both sides poured-in volunteers and resources and, like in Winnipeg-North, name recognition was the likely difference-maker for Fantino, not any alleged Conservative wave.

As for Fantino's peak-a-boo campaign, did it help or hinder? Again, hard to draw a lesson, because it could go either way. Would the Conservative margin have been bigger if they hadn't hid their rock-star candidate? Or would greater exposure have led to a gaffe that could have cost him the narrow race? Who can say.

What about the wither the NDP trend being pushed by some, with their defeat in Winnipeg-North and poor showing in Vaughan? Does it really show a two-way national race? Sorry, I'm not buying. I think in races where it's clearly a LPC/CPC race, the NDP vote will bleed LPC to stop the CPC. But in race where its clearly a NDP/CPC race, expect the LPC vote to bleed to the NDP somewhat as well. Again, local factors will be the determinant in most cases.

The Lessons

Perhaps we can't legitimately pull any trends from last night’s by-elections, but can we pull some lessons?

Definitely.

Lesson one: It’s all about the ground war. The pundits like to punditize, and we bloggers and twitterers like to trade barbs and post videos and revelations. It’s fun and entertaining, but its impact in the grand scheme of things is negligible. We saw two tight races in Winnipeg-North and Vaughan, and they were fought and won not by any ad, attack press release, soundbite or blog revelation. They were won by old-fashioned, on the ground campaigning. Knocking on doors, making phone-calls, identifying the vote and getting it out on e-day. Particularly in a by-election, voters aren’t paying attention to the air war – it’s a phony war. Boots on the ground win elections, and that’s where these races were really fought.

Lesson two: It’s hard to sense the local mood from Ottawa. It was really amusing, and saddening, to watch the national media and punditry seriously try to handicap these races without ever leaving the friendly confines of their offices near Parliament Hill, relying instead on the spin they’re fed by each of the parties. No wonder they thought Vaughan would be a Conservative landslide, that the Liberals were having trouble pulling volunteers, and never even saw Winnipeg-North coming. I’m not that old, but I do remember a time when reporting meant first-hand observation. If they’d visited Vaughan or Winnipeg-North to talk to residents, meet the candidates and stop by the campaign offices, they’d have gotten a much better picture of the races.

Lesson three: No one will remember these by-elections in a week. What was today’s biggest story and the big thing that will change everything will quickly be forgotten. That’s how it has always been. And particularly when the results can’t be made to fit the narrative that’s being pushed. So just relax, because life does always go on.

Finally, if you’ll permit me, a few partisan observations. Tony Genco and team ran a very impressive campaign in Vaughan, and he probably deserves a shot in the general election. With the glare of the byelection off and the PMO off running the national campaign, he just might win. Particularly since Harper won’t be able to keep Fantino muzzled forever.

And a big congrats to Kevin Lamoureux and team in Winnipeg-North, for a very impressive win against a political newcomer, but highly-respected and capable candidate in Kevin Chief.

For those looking for signs of Liberal disunity, it’s hard to find any here. From what I hear, Genco in Vaughan had more volunteers than he knew what to do with, which is a great sign of how committed and energized Liberals on the ground are, and bodes well for the next election. Same in Winnipeg. A major inhibitor for the Liberals in the last few election as been their inability to identify and marshal the Liberal vote, and find the volunteers to run an effective GOTV operation. These results bode well for the next race.

Finally, it was nice to see the Liberals finally get it right on expectations management, and even beat the Conservatives on that font. They under-promised -- sending-out signals of a huge defeat in Vaughan and little chance in Winnipeg-North – and then over-delivered with a tight defeat and a narrow victory. A nice change from the recent trend of over-promise, under-deliver.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Wednesday, November 24, 2010

No-Show Fantino slammed by Vaughan debate organizers

The Conservative candidate-in-hiding in Vaughan, Julian Fantino, skipped another all-candidates meeting last night, and the debate organizers were none too pleased:





Meanwhile, Liberal candidate Tony Genco gave up a night with his daughter and Justin Bieber to take part in this exercise in democracy.
Genco pointed out that he had tickets to go with his daughter to the Justin Bieber concert for her birthday, but she gave him permission not to attend.

“I made my choice, other candidates have made theirs,” he said, as the auditorium erupted in applause.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Monday, November 15, 2010

Why is Julian Fantino in the Conservative Candidate Protection Program?

Anyone who knows anything about Julian Fantino knows that he’s no shrinking violet. Quite the opposite, actually. Which makes his peak-a-boo campaign in the Vaughan by-election all the more surprising.


There were signs early on that the Ottawa boys in the Prime Minister’s Office wanted to clamp a muzzle on their “star candidate” when, at his campaign launch event, the PMO tried to stop Fantino from talking to the media.
“I think this is the place that best fits my desires to make, hopefully, a significant difference on the things that threaten Canada, of which Vaughan is very much a part,” he told reporters after a Harper handler initially barred the media from speaking to him.
While Fantino was able to temporarily shake off the muzzle, it appears the boys in Ottawa have their wayward candidate back under their thumb. We’re a few weeks into the campaign and Fantino is still refusing to participate in an all candidates meeting with his opponents to debate the issues facing the residents of Vaughan. It’s been a week since Liberal candidate Tony Genco challenged Fantino to an open debate and, still, its crickets from Fantino.
“Voters will decide this election in just two weeks and Julian Fantino still won’t commit to debating healthcare, retirement security, and jobs in Vaughan” said Mr. Genco. “Vaughan residents should be given the opportunity to see for themselves that a vote for Julian Fantino is a vote for Stephen Harper’s wasteful spending and misplaced priorities.”
Fantino’s capture by the Harper straight-jacket is not going un-noticed. People are starting to ask just when Fantino is going to come out of hiding and start coming clean with the people of Vaughan on the issues.
Retired OPP Commissioner Julian Fantino is in political protective custody, his critics say.

The usually blunt speaking Fantino, the Conservative’s candidate in the Nov. 29 Vaughan federal by-election appears to be running a textbook peek-a-boo campaign.

He’s become a kind of virtual candidate. Voters can follow him on Twitter and listen to his messages on the campaign website but have yet to see him debate his opponents.

The Toronto Star had no luck reaching Fantino or even his office despite several calls and an email.
Just what is the Harper PMO hiding Fantino from? Why don’t they want Fantino to speak his mind freely? What are they afraid of?

My guess is that the PMO doesn’t want Fantino trying to defend an indefensible Harper record that is out of touch with the priorities of the people of Vaughan. Like dropping $16 billion on stealth fighters without competion, instead of investing in priorities that Vaughan shares such as health and home care, pension reform and education. Or maybe they don’t want to defend their attempt to kill a gun registry that Vaughan residents support as an important public safety tool.

Of course, it could be that Fantino seems to be having trouble even getting Conservatives onside.
Former provincial police commissioner Julian Fantino can expect a heated campaign as the Conservative candidate in an upcoming Ontario byelection — and not just from his political opponents.

A group calling itself Conservatives Against Fantino says it will hold protests outside Fantino's campaign office over five days leading up to the Nov. 29 byelection in Vaughan, north of Toronto
.
Actually, it’s no wonder the Harper PMO wants to keep Fantino in a box and away from the public. He has a lot to answer for. And it’s not like it’s a new strategy for the Conservatives. The Harper muzzle was out in full force in the last election, and in by-elections past.

And, of course, it’s not likely the muzzle gets loosened once a candidate is elected. No Conservative MP says boo without an OK from the un-elected young turks in the PMO. Just look how vocal the Saskatchewan Conservative caucus was (or wasn't) on the potash issue. The entire province was consumed with the issue, and the Conservative MPs were MIA.

It seems the question for Vaughan voters is this: do they really want to send another neutered Harper lackey to Ottawa? Or do they want an MP like Tony Genco, who last week reached over 8700 Vaughan residents in a telephone townhall?

It's hard to be in touch with the priorities of Vaughan when you've been ordered to avoid the people of Vaughan, Mr. Fantino.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Saturday, October 16, 2010

Muzzle Watch 2010: PMO trying to shield Julian Fantino from media?

Stephen Harper was in Vaughan on Friday to help launch former top OPP and Toronto cop Julian Fantino's campaign as the Conservative candidate in the yet to be scheduled by-election.


A few interesting things emerged from the coverage, such as the revelation that apparently Ontario PC leader Tim Hudak didn't show him the love, or perhaps he might have run provincially.

“I think this is the place that best fits my desires to make, hopefully, a significant difference on the things that threaten Canada, of which Vaughan is very much a part,” he told reporters after a Harper handler initially barred the media from speaking to him.
Could it be that the infamous Harper muzzle is back? After all, Conservative candidates have a long history of dodging the media, all candidates meetings, and other unscripted public interaction.

It appears Fantino has fought off the attempted muzzling, at least for now. He's certainly not the sort to calmly consent to keeping his mouth shut. We'll have to see if they try to slip the muzzle back on as the campaign gets underway.

I, for one, look forward to hearing what Fantino has to say on the issues of the day. Particularly on all the things he thinks threaten Canada, of which he assures us Vaughan is very much a part. Certainly, his past comments on a variety of issues have proved noteworthy.

Also, this site would seem worth watching: Conservatives Against Fantino.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers