Showing posts with label Liberal Leadership 2012. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Liberal Leadership 2012. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

10,000 Liberal supporters a very real number: Certosimo

Following-up on my post earlier this week about some of my concerns around the Liberal Party of Canada’s supporter sign-up process, I spoke today with Liberal membership secretary Matthew Certosimo about the process and the philosophy behind how it’s set up.


In summary, he feels the 10,000 supporters signed-up in the first month figure is a firm and very real number, due to the multi-stage verification process I’ll outline. And the number continues to grow. The party feels pre-checking the box is a standard industry practice for companies that communicate via web forms, but he will look at adding more language, either on the petition form or through a link, to illuminate just what being a supporter means.

More broadly, he described a system to bring supporters into the party that acts as a funnel at the top to bring in every possible, and gets narrower down the funnel to ensure that a) they actually do want to be supporters, and later b) that they’re qualified to vote for leader. That’s to deal with the two competing objectives of the system: wanting to broaden the tent while also needing to ensure the veracity of the list.

He described a multi-stage process. First, someone takes the first step to be a supporter by signing-up on the Web page or through a petition or other outreach method. At that point, they're providing minimal information and may not know too much about what that entails.  They’ll then receive a follow-up e-mail from party president Mike Crawley asking them to confirm that they do indeed want to be a supporter that provides more information about what that involves, and asks them for more information, as well as to affirm they support Liberal principles and aren’t a member of another party.

If they don’t provide the follow-on information, they may stay on a mailing-list but they don’t become official supporters. And while there’s the possibility of people ending up on the list that didn’t intend to be, Certosimo said this second stage is where they can ask off. And he said while 10,000 supporters signed-up in the first month, he said only 30 said they were on the list in error and wanted off. A pretty low error rate.

And before any supporter will get a ballot to vote in a leadership race, he said there will be a further process of verification and credentialing. Those rules are to be determined by an ad hoc committee on leadership rules. The method of leadership voting is still to be determined. Verification that a supporter exists and is qualified to vote would be easier to do if there’s physical (as opposed to online voting), but physical polling would be a difficult logistical exercise given the potential size of a voting pool that includes supporters. But Certosimo said whatever process is decided on will have to be one in which everyone can have confidence in the veracity of the supporter list. Campaigns, as is usual in a leadership race, will also have the opportunity to challenge the credentials of any voter.

Certosimo stressed that he pushed to launch the supporters system in May because he wanted the summer as a period to experiment and work the kinks out of the system, before leadership concerns begin to influence everything in the fall. He indicated the anecdotal reports I’ve heard of false positives were likely a result of unverified new supporter sign-ups being forwarded daily to riding presidents, along with new member and donor data. The supporter data is now being forwarded every 12 days, so it has undergone the preliminary verification to weed-out any false positives from the data riding associations are getting.

On my specific concerns about the supporter box on petitions, he said they discussed the pre-click decision and they felt it was an industry-standard practice employed by other companies that conduct these sorts of communications, and emphasized again the idea is to bring in as many people as possible in phase one, and verify their intentions in the next phase. As for the lack of information on the petition about what being a supporter is, he said they want to keep that page tight and much of that information comes in the verification e-mail. He will, though, look to see if more information could be added, perhaps via a link.

So, in short, 10,000 is a real number and is getting higher, backed by a multi-stage verification process.

I feel better knowing that there are multiple stages of verification, and the low false positive rate is also very encouraging. I would still prefer we ask people to make a more informed decision up front rather than funnel them in and then verify, but I understand where they’re coming from. And I’m glad there will be further verification before anyone gets a leadership ballot.

As mentioned that process is still being determined, and it will be incredibly important. My fear is that an online process could lead to unscrupulous organizers signing-up multiple people, either invented or real without their knowledge, and voting all their PINs online. Whatever process is created will need to ensure these are real people, and they are actually casting their own ballot, without coercion. While physical voting locations would be a major logistical challenge, it may be the only way to do this thing with confidence.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

A Coyne (not that one) enters the race and a BCer (not me) comes close

With summer underway the Liberal  Party of Canada leadership race is starting to heat up (yes, I do feel horrible for writing that) with a few recent developments to report.

For one, a Coyne has declared (no, not Andrew). It's Deborah Coyne, who will have to remind the media that she does indeed have a first name, and isn't just "Justin Trudeau's half-sister's mother" as one media outlet akwardly put it this morning. Or just Andrew's cousin.

...she says she’s running because she believes Canadians are fed up with polarizing partisanship and that gives the Liberal party a golden opportunity to re-emerge from its current third-party status as the party of “bold, principled” national leadership on important public policy questions. 
“I’m in this to make sure it’s an ideas-based campaign. I believe I have a vision and a program that will resonate with many Canadians.” 
While the media will make much of the Trudeau family connection, particularly if Justin runs, Coyne is a very accomplished candidate with solid Liberal pedigree. She's a public policy and constitutional law expert and ran for the Liberals in Toronto-Danforth against Jack Layton in 2006. Some of her ideas merit consideration (she's pro-carbon tax) and she's anti-merger with the NDP. 


Glancing at her policy proposals I think her main issue right now is that which all Liberals wrestle with: taking big-picture theory and relating it to Canadians, who are more focused on pocket-book issues that impact their day-to-day lives. Anyway, she's a solid entry into the race.


Meanwhile, in the all but declared category is David Merner, who has been doing the exploratory thing and resigned yesterday as president of the federal party's BC wing to focus on his possible leadership run. Here's the letter he sent to members:
I am writing to let you know that I have decided to step down as President of the Liberal Party of Canada in British Columbia. Our Vice President, Brian Rice, will step in to the Presidency, as provided under our Constitution. 
 I've really enjoyed the opportunity to work with the riding Presidents, Caucus members, party staff, the BC Executive and the National Board. However, I am leaving the Presidency to focus on fund raising and other activities that are essential to participating in the Liberal leadership race as a candidate. 
Wherever I meet experienced Liberals across Canada, I hear "You guys in BC are amazing". That's true. We have outstanding leaders throughout BC. To name only a few members of our Executive, Brian Rice is recognized as a leader on riding development; Ray Larson is known as one of the Party's leading micro-targetting experts; and Mary Pynenburg and Ken Halliday are leading the national Women's Commission and national Seniors' Commission respectively. In sum, the LPCBC Executive is in great hands.
Under Brian's leadership and with a hugely talented membership that is 5,000 strong, I am positive that BC will continue to lead by example in rebuilding our Party. We are moving along the long, steep road to recovery from last year's defeat, thanks to the steps that party members and supporters are taking every day. I look forward to continuing on that journey together.

Merner's organizing has been out in the open for some time, and my understanding is that it was basically crap or get off the pot time as far as his continued role as LPCBC president while planning a leadership run. While I'm a transplanted BCer I've never met the fellow so I've no insight on him to share, although he did recently speak with fellow blogger Impolitical who shares some details today.


Another tire-kicker, former Ottawa-Orleans candidate David Betschi, as in Toronto for a pub last night. I'd planned to attend but was otherwise engaged. He's a lawyer who has also been doing the exploratory thing. One piece of advice: if your policy page is called "Where I Stand" a few more stands would be nice. 


CP reports another declared candidate I've never heard of:
Shane Geschiere, a 32-year-old Manitoba paramedic with no political experience, is the only other person so far to openly declare his intention to enter the race.
And Martha-Hall Findlay continues to gain profile with her stance on supply management (which Coyne appears to share). She really needs to pay off that 2006 debt though; I would have a problem with any candidates still carrying past leadership debt entering this one. (You can donate to her debt here if you're so inclined.)


The Star's Susan Delacourt had a pretty exhaustive list of possible candidates on the weekend.


I suspect we'll see the tire-kickers begin to fade away once the rules for the leadership race are set, probably this fall, particularly around the entry fee and spending cap. Personally, my preference is for an entry fee high enough to keep the field manageable and race serious, and a cap low enough that campaigns can do what they need to do without incurring heavy debt and sucking donations from the central party and riding associations. But more on that in another post.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers