I've been firmly on the record against merger, or a non-aggression pact (deceptively called cooperation -- who doesn't like cooperation?) for at least a year or two now.
I've outlined my reasons at length, from the fact that most statistical evidence indicates it just won't work (you'll lose centre-right Liberals to Harper and strengthen his vote count) to my belief that not having Liberals on the ballot in half the country would be kind of bad for those who think our party should still exist. There's also the somewhat awkward reality that there's no one to cooperate with.
I don't want to rehash all that. I've made my arguments, and I'm happy to let the debate play out and the people have their say. I think those that argue for it come to their views honestly and, while I disagree, I respect their position.
I do, though, want to address one talking point I've been hearing more and more from Team Non-Aggression Pact: that those who oppose their non-aggression pact are somehow putting "narrow partisan interests" ahead of the greater good, poutine, hockey and all that is holy. Besides being insulting, that argument is nonsensical.
Let me submit this: IF a non-aggression pact was indeed the silver bullet to defeat Stephen Harper, reform the electoral system and return our party to national relevance, and IF I was an unthinking uncaring partisan drone, why on Earth would I NOT support it? Surely it would be the quicker path to redemption, glory and an Ambassadorship to the Federated States of Micronesia than slogging it out as a third place party?
I am opposed to a non-aggression pact precisely because I am NOT putting narrow partisan interests first. Instead, I choose to take the harder road. Not the road of restricting voter choice, not the road of fiddling with ballots behind the scenes to leave people with no choice but to vote the way I want.
Instead, I want to take the harder road, the road of building an alternative vision, of winning the support of Canadians not by restricting their choices, but by offering them a BETTER choice. Because I believe THAT is how you win the lasting and durable support of the electorate.
It is not narrowly partisan to say that just because I don't like Stephen Harper's vision for Canada doesn't mean I like Tom Mulcair's. I believe in a vision of Canada that neither of them shares. That's why I'm supporting a candidate, and a party, whose vision I do share. It is not narrowly partisan to say my be all and end all isn't defeating Stephen Harper; just the opposite, in fact.
There are lots of arguments to make for non-aggression pacts. Accusing those that oppose them as being narrowly partisan is not one of them.
And lastly, it's there's one thing we "narrow partisans" need to stop doing, it's thinking that everyone thinks Stephen Harper is the devil. I assure you, they do not. Most Canadians, while they disagree with many of his policies, and didn't vote for him, think he's a reasonably competent if somewhat stern fellow who has done a reasonable job, all things considered. Thinking otherwise is the biggest mistake we continually make.
Make no mistake -- I fundamentally disagree with him, and I think he should be defeated. But as long as our narrow partisan goal is just to defeat him, we will lose. The non-partisans just don't share that motivation. Until we offer Canadians something better, we're doomed. That's this narrow partisan's take.
Monday, April 01, 2013
Briefly, on "cooperation"
Wednesday, January 30, 2013
Liberal members: If you want to vote for leader, you MUST register
Registering to support a candidate on their web site, or registering as a supporter on the LPC web site, is not the same thing. To be able to actually cast a vote, you must complete the process outlined below.
Tuesday, January 15, 2013
Deborah Coyne meets the press
It's been a busy few days for Liberal leadership candidate Deborah Coyne, doing several media interviews around the launch of her new ebook Unscripted: A Life Devoted to Building a Better Canada. Here's a few of the interviews where she talks about the book, the leadership race, why she's running, and how she believes we can get more Canadians off the sidelines and engaged in political life once more.
Monday, January 14, 2013
Five things you may not know about Deborah Coyne
- Deborah’s history in the Liberal Party goes back to 1983, when she was elected to then party president Iona Campagnolo’s reform commission. Along with Alf Apps, Ed Roberts, Gordon Gibson and others, she worked for three years on a proposed reform package. One key recommendation, a council of riding presidents, was only implemented a few years ago, proving our party has a long history of studying reform, but less success actually implementing it.
- She served as Ontario policy chair on John Turner’s successful leadership campaign and would work in the Prime Minister's Office during his brief tenure as Prime Minister.
- She would first come to national prominence as one of the leaders in the fight against the Meech Lake Accord, which is ironic, as she spent most of her childhood summers at a cottage on the shores of Meech Lake, accessible only by boat. One of her fellow co-founders of the Coalition on the Constitution was Michael Ignatieff’s father, George.
- A source of inspiration for her decision to seek the leadership was attending Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert’s “Rally forSanity” in Washington. Knowing the same frustration that drew 250,000 people to the National Mall also holds true in Canada, she decided it can’t just be comedians that give voice to our collective frustration.
- While a student at Oxford University in England, she established its first Women’s Ice Hockey Club and helped establish a women’s league. She captained the Oxford team her first year, scoring a goal in the inaugural game loss against Cambridge. The league is still going strong today.
Monday, October 01, 2012
The Liberal Party needs a competitive race
With the rules that will govern the race now in place and more candidates about to put their names forward, the race for the Liberal Party of Canada is about to move from the quiet summer exploratory phase to a season of coast-to-coast fall campaigning. Officially, the starting gun will sound Nov. 15th, and when the entry fees are due we’ll have a better sense of the real field.
So it seems an appropriate time to stress the importance for the party that this be a real, true, competitive race that showcases the best ideas, policies and personalities that the Liberal Party has to offer the Canadian people. When Liberal members created the supporter system, we bet a lot on this leadership race being a major part of our rebuilding and rejuvenation. If we want people to sign up as supporters of our party for the chance to vote for our next leader, we need to offer them a competitive and dynamic race where their vote can make a difference.
I've been hearing a lot of talk about coronations. Not only would that be unfortunate for the party, depriving us of the opportunity to attract public and media attention (and supporters) with a competitive field of dynamic candidates debating their visions for the future of our country, it also wouldn't be that great for the crowned. Our next leader will be better positioned and able to face down Stephen Harper and Thomas Mulcair if they've had to explain and defend their positions in a competitive and respectful race, rising as the victor from spirited debates with a strong cast of challengers. They’ll emerge the stronger for it, and so will the party.
Ensuring a competitive race though will require Liberals to seek out candidates that best represent their own vision, values and outlook, and support them in the race. And this is made easier by our new system of preferential balloting. There’s no reason to make a reluctant strategic vote any longer. With the ability to rank your choices (one, two, three, etc.) you can support and rank first the candidates whose vision best matches your own.
We can all agree that coronations aren't positive, but it’s up to each of us, every Liberal, to get involved and ensure we have the leadership race that this party needs and deserves.
Saturday, September 22, 2012
Liberal leadership procedure and process update from Mike Crawley
Today was the Liberal Party of Canada (Ontario)’s Toronto region day,
where Liberals from the ridings of greater Toronto gathered
to talk organization, policy and
rebuilding. A few items of interest to share, particularly on the leadership
front.
Anyway, today our post-lunch speaker was Liberal Party of
Canada president Mike Crawley, who gave attendees an update on where things are
at with the leadership process. I’ll assume you’ve read the rules that were posted recently as far as entry fee and spending caps, so I won’t rehash that. He did share some new items of interest
though, but I’ll stress these items are still fluid and aren’t
yet official. I’d guess he was discussing the evolving thinking of the adhoc
rules committee (committee member Christine Innes was also present), which will
make recommendations that must be approved (and could be modified) by the national
board. So it’s all subject to change.

