Showing posts with label BC Liberal Leadership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BC Liberal Leadership. Show all posts

Sunday, February 27, 2011

A new premier and a new dynamic in British Columbia

A big win last night on the left coast for Christy Clark, who scored a third-ballot victory in the BC Liberal Party race over Kevin Falcon and managed to get her victory speech in before the Canucks game started. Unfortunately the Canucks would fall to the Boston Bruins, but otherwise a pretty good night for British Columbia.


It was interesting watching the evening unfold from afar, as the media tried to figure out how to cover a (weighted) one member, one vote non-convention as opposed to the old-style made for tv delegated drama. The members voted across the province throughout the day Saturday online and on the phone with a single preferential ballot. More democratic than a delegated convention, but less for the media to do.

The party did try to squeeze what drama it could out of the system. Rather than just announce the winner straight-out, it announced the results of each ballot in 10-minute increments. Surprising the final result didn't leak to Twitter early. I thought it was a little surprising George Abbott didn't do better on the first ballot, but him and Kevin Falcon were fishing in the same pool. Not surprised Clark wasn't higher on the first ballot, everyone was trying to spin-up her numbers as part of the expectations game. What was surprising was that the rumours of Clark's lack of second-choice support were shown false. There was no anybody but Christy movement; Clark gained steadily as Mike DeJong and Abbott fell off the ballot.

As a BCer at heart, I'm optimistic about Clark's victory.When I was still living in BC I let my BC Liberal membership lapse, disappointed that the Liberal/Conservative coalition (out there it's not a dirty word) had tilted much too right for my liking as the Campbell government went on. I'm hopeful that Clark can move the party and the government back toward the progressive centre. Time will tell, of course, but I'm hopeful.

The challenge, of course, will be holding that coalition together. Clark is seen by many as a "Liberal" candidate, viewed with wariness by some on the "Conservative" side of the party. There were abandon the party warnings by some if she won, and the upstart BC Conservative Party is waiting in the wings. I suspect many of the warnings were just electioneering, but the BC Conservative leadership race will be worth watching.

The other challenge for Clark will be uniting a caucus that, with one exception, supported other people. This, I think, will be less of a challenge than it has been hyped to be. It's one team now, and with the NDP soon to have a new leader, everyone knows where the focus should be.

Oh, and of course, Clark needs to find a riding to run in and get herself into the legislature.

So we'll now watch to see how Clark builds her cabinet and begins governing, while the NDP (and the BC Conservatives) continue their leadership races. Once we know all the players, and get a sense of how Clark will be governing (and how the HST referendum goes) we'll have a better sense of what the future holds. But always interesting times on the left coast.


Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Are we ready for online voting?

Are we ready for online voting? It's an idea that's on the table for debate in British Columbia, where BC Liberal leadership candidate Christy Clark put it forward recently as something we should consider and discuss, with several of the other candidates quickly agreeing its an idea worth exploring:




Online voting sounds like a nice idea in theory. You'd obviously still have physical polls, but online voting would make it a lot easier for people to vote, would encourage young people that live online to vote, and could well increase voter turnout.

Nice in theory, but I have some serious concerns I'd need satisfied before I'd ever consider supporting online voting.

We actually had a debate on this at the last federal Liberal biennial in Vancouver during the constitutional plenary, when the delegates considered an amendment that would have opened the door to online voting for nomination races.

I went into the debate supporting the amendment from the perspective of someone who grew up in a massive rural riding, where we either had to run multiple polls or ask people to drive for hours to cast a vote. But during the debate the nays had me reconsidering.

Online voting is so anonymous. How do we do who is sitting at that computer, and that they actually are who they say they are? Someone could have gathered-up a bunch of PINs and be voting them. Maybe someone moved, the new residents got their PIN in the mail and is casting their ballots.

How do you guard against persuasion and intimidation? In a physical polling place, unless they need assistance a voter must go to the voting screen alone, and can cast a secret ballot. What's to stop an abusive spouse or partner from standing over the computer and making sure they "vote correctly?"

And then there's the IT security issue. How long before someone hacks the system, destroys or compromises records, and puts the integrity of the result into question? As a journalist my day job is covering the technology sector, and I'm not confident of its ability to keep a system safe and secure.

The beauty of our current system is its simplicity. We go to the voting place, show our id, and get a ballot. We mark an X for one person, and put it in a box. The staff count up all the ballots, the results are tabulated, and a winner declared. If there's a discrepancy or a challenge, we go back to the physical ballots and re-count them. There's virtue in that simplicity. Technology doesn't make everything better.

And not for nothing, but how easy do we really need to make it to vote? Is taking 30 minutes out of your life every couple of years to go to an elementary school gymnasium and mark an X really that much of a sacrifice to make for our democracy? Shouldn't voting require some level of commitment, of engagement, of effort?

As I said, I like the theory of online voting. I'm glad we're having the debate, and that the BC Liberal race is seeing a lot of interesting ideas put on the table. But they've got a long ways to go to convince me online voting could be viable, practicable, and desirable.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Wednesday, January 05, 2011

What do merit pay, a carbon tax and Tommy Chong have in common?

Out to British Columbia again, where the candidates for the leadership of the BC Liberal Party have been busy lately talking policy ideas.

Kevin Falcon took a controversial position this week when he argued for merit pay for teachers and cash incentives for schools and teachers that improve test scores.

If he wins the leadership contest next month, Falcon said he would create a master teacher incentive program that would recognize exceptional and innovative educators and a model school incentive program that would reward schools for improvements in student achievement.

…his plan wouldn't rely solely on test scores. Rather, he said his government would work with teachers, administrators, parents and community leaders to develop criteria for identifying innovative educators.

Falcon’s proposal sparked a firestorm of criticism. The BC Teachers Federation, predictably, called it “a cockamamie notion” and his leadership opponent, former education minister George Abbott, said it would amount to cherry-picking one element of failed U.S. experiments in education.

Mr. Abbott said he was opposed to throwing “one experimental or trick shot piece out there that is drawn from the American experience and may not be applicable to our experience,” into education policy in this province.

Still no word, by the way, on Falcon's flip-flop on lowering the voting age from 18 to 16.

Abbott made his own major policy push yesterday, and it wasn’t without its own controversial policy positions. For example, remember the carbon tax? While it helped fell Stephane Dion, BC’s own carbon tax, while controversial at its inception, remains quietly in place in BC. The BC Liberals won the last election despite a concerted effort by the BC NDP to defeat them on the carbon tax. Still, Abbott wants to revive the issue with a referendum:

The carbon tax referendum would be held June 24, which is also the date Abbott proposes for bringing forward the provincewide vote (currently set for Sept. 24) on whether to extinguish the harmonized sales tax.

Abbott said many British Columbians are rightly proud of the trail blazing carbon tax, which is scheduled to climb to seven cents a litre effective July 1, 2012. But he questioned whether the province should continue with such a tax when, as he put it, "the rest of North American is not dancing with us on this issue."

So, rather that being an environmental leader and continuing with a carbon tax, the system increasingly favoured not just by environmentalists but even by the energy industry, Abbott wants to re-open the can of worms? It’s an absolutely horrible idea. I can only surmise he seems some political advantage if he can rile up people on the issue, but it’s both bad policy and bad politics in my view. It is (was) a dead issue. I agree with Falcon on this one:

But Falcon rejected Abbott's call for a referendum, saying, "we had a referendum on the carbon tax and it was called the general election."

While it didn’t get the attention of merit pay for teachers or a carbon tax referendum, I was more disturbed by Abbott’s senate musings:

He also said the province should follow the route of Alberta and begin electing senate nominees.

When one of B.C.'s six seats in the Canadian Senate becomes vacant, a provincewide election would be held. The winner's name would then be forwarded to the prime minister for appointment to fill the vacancy.

Sounds nice in theory, but in reality it’s bad for the Senate and bad for British Columbia. I’ve blogged about this at length in the past, but in short, BC is very ill-served by the current composition of the Senate.

While the Commons is representation by population (in theory), the Senate is meant to balance that with representation by region. The problem is, the current regional make-up of the Senate is outdated, and is based on a 19th century view of confederation-era Canada. The Maratimes are vastly over represented. Dido Upper and Lower Canada. The West, meanwhile, is lumped together as one regional group.

This inequity, while grating, is less pressing while the Senate is composed of unelected sober second thoughters that, recognizing their constitutional illegitimacy, are loathe (well, usually loathe) to circumvent the will of the elected Commons.

However, if you elect senators as Harper and Abbott favour, then those elected senators will be able to claim a democratic mandate and will not hesitate to exercise their not insubstantial constitutional powers.

Creating elected senators without addressing the regional composition of the Senate and addressing the balance of powers between the house of parliament is a bad idea, and it’s bad for BC. I’ll say to Abbott what I’ve long said (well, blogged) to Harper: you shouldn’t do senate reform half-assed. It has to be all or nothing.

Meanwhile, Christy Clark yesterday launched a series of open government initiatives aimed at increasing public confidence and public participation in the democratic process. It included a promise to, as Premier, hold a dozen town halls each year with BC residents.

“The reality is that voters feel a disconnect with their government,” said the former deputy premier and education minister.

“These proposals are designed to reconnect people with government.”

Other proposals put forward by Ms.Clark include working with all MLAs to see more private members’ bills debated and passed as well as a caucus accountability committee with the party leader as member, and cabinet accountability sessions in the regions of B.C. at regional policy conferences or other special events.
More on the specific proposals is available here. Some are more ambitious than others, but I like the monthly townhalls and more streaming video of legislative and committee meetings.

As for the BC NDP

While I don’t agree with all of their ideas, I have been impressed with the level of policy-focused debate we’ve seen in the BC Liberal leadership race. Meanwhile, over on the BC NDP side, Dana Larsen remains the only declared candidate. He has, however, secured a key endorsement:

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Monday, January 03, 2011

B.C. leadership round-up: Dana Larsen vs NDP bosses, and a Falcon flip-flop?

While the rest of Canada may have slowed-down for the Christmas break, with two leadership races underway on the left coast the wackiness continued as per usual in Supernatural British Columbia.

The BC NDP

* We’ll start with the BC NDP, and the slow to start race to replace Carole James. With potential candidates slow to surface, we finally had someone step forward and put their name into the race over the break, and it’s a familiar name: rabble-rousing marijuana crusader Dana Larsen.
Former West Vancouver-Sunshine Coast federal NDP candidate and marijuana advocate Dana Larsen announced Wednesday that he will run for the leadership of the B.C. New Democrats.

Larsen said he had no plans of pursuing a leadership role until Carole James stepped down from the position in early December, but said he decided to throw his hat in the ring because he wanted to offer "a fresh perspective" to party members and the B.C. electorate.

In an interview with The Outlook, Larsen said he hopes to take the B.C. NDP back to "grassroots" politics and re-establish the party as "unabashedly left wing." Renewed support for low-income and seniors' housing, he said, are two issues at the top of his agenda.

As Troy McClure would say, you may remember Dana Larsen from past scandals was forced to resign as a federal candidate over video of himself driving a car while high on LSD (actually, see update below), or banned from the NDP convention in Halifax by Brad Lavigne.

Yes, we first came to know Larsen as the NDP candidate in West Vancouver-Sunshine Coast-Really Long Riding Name in the 2008 federal election. Larsen was the first of three NDP candidates to drop out of the race in BC after YouTube video surfaced of Larsen “dropping hallucinogenic drugs and driving while smoking marijuana.”

He resurfaced the next year in the lead-up to the NDP’s 2009 federal convention in Halifax, when he offered financial assistance to potential delegates as part of his campign to pass pro-legalization policy at convention. NDP executive director Brad Lavigne viewed this as improper lobbying and had him banned from the convention hall on conference eve, creating somewhat of a martyr.

It seems Larsen still doesn’t have many friends in the NDP leadership. While Larsen wants to run for the BC leadership, BC NDP boss Moe Sihota is throwing cold-water on the prospect:
But NDP provincial secretary Moe Sihota said Larsen was declared ineligible to run for the party after the 2008 federal election campaign when he had to step down as a candidate in a Vancouver-area riding after videos appeared of him smoking pot and taking LSD.

Sihota also counted Larsen out on a technicality, which he said ultimately could prevent Larsen from running provincially at all.

"He's not a member of the party," said Sihota. "He was already deemed ineligible to run for the party federally and the rules committee, which meets on Jan. 6, would have to decide whether he would be able to run provincially."
It appears some of the confusion may have been addressed, and Larsen does indeed now have a membership, although he says he had, or should have, had one all along. I was interested to read Sihota’s characterization of Larsen’s departure from the 2008 race though. Sihota said Larsen “was deemed ineligible to run for the party federally” but the news coverage at the time made clear Larsen wasn’t forced-out but stepped aside voluntarily:
Asked about Mr. Larsen’s resignation Wednesday evening in Toronto, NDP Leader Jack Layton said he didn’t know why the party hadn’t done checks to find out about some of the candidate’s activities, which are posted on the Internet. He said the candidate submitted the resignation to the B.C. campaign team and that it was accepted.

“I don’t know a lot of the details of what’s gone on there, but he’s obviously taken the decision that he’s not a suitable candidate, and we’ve accepted that decision.”
* It could all be moot anyway, barring gender-reassignment surgery. Because it appears an arcane part of the BC NDP’s constitution requires the next leader to be female:
The next leader of the B.C. NDP will have to be a woman, unless the party's male president or treasurer resigns, according to gender rules in the NDP constitution.

The unique requirement, buried within the NDP's official rulebook, adds an extra layer of complexity in the race to replace leader Carole James.

The constitution states both genders must be represented in the jobs of leader, president and treasurer.

The current president is Moe Sihota and the treasurer is Bob Smits. James is stepping down later this month, and all those who have publicly said they are considering the job are men.

This is yet another example of why I think hard quotas are a clumsy way of achieving demographic parity, and are generally a bad idea. I might add that the BC Liberals didn’t need quotas to attract two quality female candidates in Moira Stilwell and the frontrunner, Christy Clark.

BC Liberals

*Over in BC Liberal land, meanwhile, we may have our first flip-flop of the campaign, on the proposal floated a few weeks back to lower the voting age to 16. When Mike de Jong first floated the idea, and Christy Clark quickly expressed support, Kevin Falcon did as well, in a statement that’s still on his Web site:
“Lowering the voting age to 16 is an interesting idea. One I am inclined to support, in conjunction with mandatory civics courses as a part of the high school curriculum. I should add that I am proud to be a member of a party that allows 14 year olds to become full members and commence their engagement as citizens before they get to vote.

“We need to recognize however, that lowering the voting age will not solve all the problems of lack of engagement with citizens. As it is, voter turn-out is unacceptably low in BC. What I am interested in is hearing from people about what we can do collectively to make sure that more people are encouraged to exercise their vote.”
However, just a week later, in a Dec. 21 interview with Harjinder Thind on Red FM, Flacon appeared to back away from that position:
Harjinder Thind: Are you in favour of increasing the minimum wage, or, decreasing the voting age?

Kevin Falcon: I am not in favour of decreasing the voting age because I think that we already are having trouble getting 18 to 24 year olds voting. But, I am interested in reaching out to those young people the way I have done through my leadership campaign by using social media and by using our website and Flicker and facebook and Twitter to connect with young people and we're doing that very successfully.
I hope Falcon will explain his apparent 180 on this issue. And I have to say, reaching out to the kids on the Twitter is nice, but if the message you’re tweeting is I don’t think you should have the vote, you’re missing the point.

*Back to gender, Keith Baldrey analyzes recent polling data and shows a strong shift of the female vote away from the BC NDP to the BC Liberals:
The NDP has long prided itself as a champion of the interests of women, and it even implemented an affirmative action policy to ensure more female candidates in the last election. But it is now seen as the party that undemocratically turfed a female leader, and it will undoubtedly elect a man to succeed Carole James.

In fact, it will be interesting to see if any women even run for the NDP leadership. If none do, it will be a stunning commentary about the party's true commitment to the interests of women.

Meanwhile, the B.C. Liberals couldn't be happier about this. The polls show the NDP's loss in support from women is in the double-digits, as many have gone over to the B.C. Liberals.
*Lastly, Christy Clark is talking about putting families first:



UPDATE: In an e-mail, Larsen clarifies that he did not drive while under the influence of LSD. There is a video of him taking LSD, and a separate video of him driving with an unlit joint. Media coverage indicates the driving video was while under the influence of DMT (dimethyltryptamine), but he says it had worn off before he drove. Says Larsen:
"Despite the media hype, in the two videos in question I am shown to be a responsible user of psychedelics. I do regret the brief segment which shows me driving with an unlit joint in my hand. I advocate for responsible use and don't support driving impaired."

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Thursday, December 16, 2010

In BC Liberal race it’s all about the kids

It’s early days in the BC Liberal race, but so far we’ve seen several notable efforts by the candidates to reach out to the youth vote. Which is smart, because people as young as 14 are eligible to join the BC Liberal Party and vote in this leadership race.


The first youth-friendly policy initiative of the campaign came from leadership candidate Christy Clark, who promised to raise the minimum wage (BC’s is the lowest in the country at $8/hour) and, more importantly for youth, scrap the training wage:
Clark said she’d raise the minimum wage above the $8 an hour mark, now the lowest in the country, and wants to scrap the $6 training wage given to young workers.

“We shouldn’t have the lowest minimum wage in the country. Whatever the minimum wage is, it should be the wage for everybody.”
Scrapping the training wage is a no-brainer ... but then again, the BC Liberals were completely brain-dead when they implemented the training wage in the first place because it’s a thoroughly stupid policy. The training wage allows employers to pay employees with no experience a wage below minimum wage for their first 500 hours of employment. Usually, it’s youth that get hit hardest. It’s discriminatory and exploitive, and it has to go.

As for the minimum wage, the current national average is $9.28, ranging from the low of $8 in BC to a high of $10.25 (with a few exceptions) in Ontario. I think BC should raise it to at least $10, and that’s still barely a living wage.

The voting age

In an even bigger move to court the youth demographic, leadership candidate Mike De Jong said Wednesday he favours lowering the voting age from 18 to 16 to get more youth civicly engaged before leaving high school.
"What happens now is Grade 12 students leave and the vast majority of them never vote, or if they do, they are 40 or 50 by the time they get around to it," he said.

Lowering the voting age could also help boost low voter turnout, he said. Only 51 per cent of 3.24 million eligible voters cast ballots in the 2009 B.C. election, down from 58 per cent in 2005 and 55 per cent in 2001.

Following De Jong’s commitment, Christy Clark said on Twitter and Facebook that she supported De Jong’s proposal.
I support Mike de Jong’s call to lower the voting age. Let’s get people in the voting habit earlier.
There’s no doubt a call to lower the voting age is obviously smart leadership politics. But is it smart policy? I’m inclined to say absolutely, but with one caveat: the move must be accompanied with focused and comprehensive non-partisan high school curriculum to engage and educate young people in civic issues.

We all know that youth voter turnout is low. Frankly, it’s low for everyone. In any demographic there are plenty of people that just don’t give a darn. But it’s a mistake to say that, overall, youth are apathetic. Many youth are concerned and engaged, they just don’t see the traditional political process as particularly relevant to them and affecting real change on the issues they care about. (In that, at least, the youth aren’t alone.)

Lowering the voting age is good leadership politics. A solid comprehensive plan to actually engage youth would make it great policy.

And a poll

In other BC political news, an interesting new Mustel poll out this morning gives the BC Liberals a five point edge among decided voters over the NDP, 41 to 36. It's a flip from last month's Mustel poll that had it NDP 42 BC Liberals 37, and appears fueled by a shift in female support away from the NDP to the BC Liberals.

On the leadership front, Mustel also shows strong support for Christy Clark, among both the general public and BC Liberals:
Former deputy premier Clark enjoys a strong lead over her leadership opponents, according to the Mustel poll, with support from 27 per cent of all voters, followed by Kevin Falcon at 11 per cent, George Abbott at 10 per cent, Mike de Jong at seven per cent and Moira Stilwell at two per cent.

When first and second choices are combined among all voters, Clark has the support of 37 per cent, compared with Abbott at 22 per cent, Falcon at 19 per cent, de Jong at 18 per cent and Stilwell at five per cent.

Among Liberal supporters, Clark leads again at 46 per cent, followed by Falcon at 35 per cent, Abbott at 30 per cent, de Jong at 24 per cent and Stilwell at four per cent.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Monday, December 13, 2010

Can Christy Clark move BC past the HST?

To most that follow British Columbia politics from afar, myself included, it’s more than a little surprising that, with all the drama over the last year or two, the BC Liberals stand a more than decent chance of winning the next election.


There is one big caveat though: the BC Liberals need to get out from under and away from the Harmonized Sales Tax (HST). When she launched her campaign for the BC Liberal leadership last week, Christy Clark presented one scenario that would seem to offer the party the chance to do just that:
“Let us consider putting the proposed referendum question to a truly free vote of the Legislative Assembly. And you know how that question goes: that this house is in favour of extinguishing the harmonized sales tax. Now if this process is successful it would put the HST behind us by March 31st. If it’s successful, we would notify the federal government immediately of our intention to withdraw after the 18 months notice that’s required in the agreement. We would start to negotiate with them to get out earlier than the five-year agreement currently allows. And unfortunately, it would mean going back to the GST and the PST. But we won’t revisit the HST for another five years. It is time for British Columbia to have certainty around this question.”

“After almost a year, the public still hates the HST. And I think we need to face some hard realities here. And that is if this goes to a referendum, a real referendum, the HST will almost certainly fail. We need to take our heads out of the sand on that, and we need to get on with restoring our economy. No one is served by uncertainty.”
Personally, I think sales tax harmonization makes good economic sense and good policy sense. The devil is in the details, and you need to do everything you can to ensure it’s as close to cost-neutral as possible for taxpayers, but it makes sense on all kinds of levels. Less paperwork for businesses, less paperwork for government. And I think undoing it will be a major logistical and procedural headache.

In BC, though, the implementation was clearly bungled. After telling the public harmonization wasn’t on the agenda during the election campaign, just days later suddenly plans to harmonize were announced. It reeked of dishonesty. While it belatedly began to try to sell the public on the merits of the HST, it was never able to get over that initial perception of dishonesty.

In any democracy, you must listen to the will of the citizens, and the people of B.C. seem clear that the HST has got to go. The government has lost the battle on this one, and it’s time to move on. Prolonging this process through the referendum next fall would be pointless, and would only prolong the economic uncertainty while seeing time and resources wasted fighting a lost cause.

Clark hasn’t committed to a course of action on the HST – she plans to consult party members and the public in the weeks ahead – but her outlined option seems the best way to move the province forward and allow it to put the HST behind it. If the legislature votes to kill the HST the referendum becomes unnecessary and the process of unwinding the tax can begin.

I do have one big question though, and that’s what of the $1.6 billion in transition funding that the federal government sent to the province to sweeten the deal? It seems safe to assume the feds are going to want that money back; just saying “keep it” would hardly be fair to the other provinces. I doubt the feds would take a super hard line and demand it all back at once; this would be part of the negotiation but I could see it being paid back over time or applied over time against future transfer payments. Still, it’s going to but a crunch on the province’s budget and necessitate some tough choices that need to be part of the debate.

Anyway, here’s the video from Clark’s leadership campaign launch last week:



Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers