Showing posts with label Senate reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Senate reform. Show all posts

Friday, July 24, 2015

Ignore the shiny Senate distraction: It really is the economy, and Harper things you're stupid

The National Post's John Ivison makes a good living floating trial balloons and framing announcements on behalf of The Harper Government, so his offering Thursday night certainly got the attention of official Ottawa:
Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall are expected to appear together Friday to call for the abolition of the Senate, according to a source familiar with their plans.
Now, if you believe that Harper woke up and decided to get serious about the Senate after a decade of doing nothing to reform or get rid of it -- besides appointing a rogue's gallery of hacks, bagman and characters now answering to the justice system or under active investigation -- then I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell you. And if you think, after a decade of avoiding the provincial premiers like he owes then child support, that he's going to jump into months/years of intensive federal/provincial negotiations, then I'll throw in the Empire State building.

No, Harper did not suddenly find religion on the Senate after a decade in power. What he found was these headlines as he gears up to run for reelection:



So what is a Prime Minister who has tied his re-election to his competent economic management do when his jury-rigged balanced budget turns into his ninth straight budget deficit? Well, after blaming Justin Trudeau, Tom Mulcair and Greece didn't work, distracting the media and the public with cheap populism on Senate reform.

Let's be clear: according to the Supreme Court, abolishing the Senate would require a constitutional amendment and the unanimous support of the provinces. Putting aside the fact that abolition is a bad idea, the last thing the Canada needs is for federal and provincial governments to spend the next two years focusing on the constitution instead of the economy. Canadians don't want Meech Lake Redux; last time, Meech birthed the Reform Party and the Bloc Quebecois and got the ball rolling on another referendum in Quebec.

Canadians want economic opportunity, job prospects, and the chance to build a better life for their children, not a constitutional sideshow.

Once Harper and Wall throw a shiny red ball in front of Canadians Friday, both the NDP and the Conservatives will be on record offering Canadians years of distracting constitutional drama. And unless it involves all the first ministers living in the same house and a bachelorette giving them roses and kicking one out every week, Canadians don't have an appetite for that.

The truth is, the Harper Conservatives have no answers for Canadians on the economy, and their credibility for economic is in tatters.

Don't let Harper change the channel. Now, more than ever, it's the economy, stupid. And the Liberals have the opportunity to be the only major party offering Canadians what Harper once said he was all about: a laser focus on the economy. It's not about constitutional reform; it's about middle-class families.

Please don't wade into the constitutional muck, Liberals. Keep your eyes on the prize: it's the economy. It always has been.

UPDATE: The Conservatives apparently changed their minds sometime between Ivison's story and the scheduled announcement. Instead, Harper promised to appoint no (more) Senators. He promised the same in 2006, and then went on to appoint 56.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Trudeau’s Senate play a bold stroke. But what’s next?

I think everyone was surprised by Liberal leader Justin Trudeau’s move this morning – particularly 32 Senators – that he was removing all Senators from the Liberal parliamentary caucus, and that as Prime Minister, he would only appoint Senators selected through a non-partisan review process.


Let me break down my reaction into two areas: the politics, and the policy.

The Politics

Politically, this is a brilliant move. For a leader who has been unfairly accused of lacking policy substance, here is bold, substantive action. For an issue – Senate reform – that has seen years of empty chatter from all parties, and from the supposedly reform-championing Conservatives, just a Supreme Court reference well into the third Harper government, this is the first real, meaningful action on Senate reform we’ve seen. This isn’t a promise of change – this is change – and it’s change Canadians can understand.

Let me address some of the critiques the opposition have raised.

Is this a “smokescreen” to deflect from wrongdoing a future Auditor General report may reveal? No one has seen the report, but the law of numbers suggest some Liberal senators will probably be named, so maybe. However, you don’t punt 32 senators from your caucus and promise no more partisan appointments as a mere damage control measure – that’d be crazy. Such a move has to come from a place of firm belief. Besides, we’ll all remember they were Liberals, I’m sure.

Why did Trudeau vote against the NDP opposition day motion that called for a non-partisan Senate, and then do this? Isn’t that a flip-flop? Actually, not at all. The NDP motion was unconstitutional. The House of Commons can’t make party leaders boot people from caucus any more than it can make me grow a mustache. The NDP motion was unenforceable and unconstitutional flim-flamery masquerading as meaningful action, and was rightly defeated. But that doesn’t mean it’s unconstitutional for me to *choose* to grow a mustache. The Commons can’t make Trudeau act; but he can, and has, chosen to act, and act decisively.

They’re calling themselves Independent Liberal Senators? Doesn’t this prove this is meaningless? Hardly, and in fact, the opposite. They’re independent. They can call themselves whatever they want. I’m sure Trudeau, for narrative’s sake, would rather they call themselves the Definitely Not Liberal Anymore Senators. But he can’t tell them what to call themselves – they’re independent, they get to pick. And most of these people have been committed Liberals for decades. They joined the party because they believe in certain ideals. Their beliefs haven’t changed because they’re not Liberal Senators anymore. But now they’re free to vote and act as they wish. Sometimes that may be similar to what Liberal MPs do; sometimes it may not. As for the name, Lillian Dyck once called herself an Independent NDP Senator. The NDP leadership didn’t like it, but there was nothing they could do about it. Also, was it meaningless when Harper booted Mike Duffy, Pamela Wallin and Patrick Brazeu from the Conservative caucus?

They’re still Liberal Party of Canada members, aren’t they? Ha ha! I would assume so, yes. Should Trudeau kick them out? On what basis would he do that? I don’t believe the party constitution gives him that authority. And even if it did (I think it rests with the party executive), there would need to be a reason, specific wrongdoing. Should we prohibit Senators from joining political parties? I don’t think so. Last I checked, we had a right to freedom of association in Canada. The Charter may mention something along those lines. If a Senator wants to take out a membership card, they should have the same right to do so as a civil servant, or any other Canadian.

With this move, Trudeau has seized this day on Senate, positioned himself as a leader who takes action, and exposed the other parties as all talk when it comes to Senate reform.

The Policy

In the short term, I’m on board. Let the Senate be independent, and in the absence of constitutional reform, let’s appoint better, non-partisan people through an independent, non-partisan review and appointments process. Paul Martin and Harper have already shown the Supreme Court appointments process can be reformed for the better within the existing constitutional framework.

Longer-term though, we simply have to open up the constitution to deal with the Senate, and I’m more aligned toward abolition today than I was yesterday.

My position on Senate reform has been clear for years: redistribute seats along equal regional lines, rebalance powers to give the Senate purpose and avoid gridlock with the Commons, and elect Senators so they’re accountable to the electorate for their decisions. My vision of Senate reform requires constitutional reform, something no parties have been willing to seriously consider to date. I think we should – it needn’t be scary at all.

Now, an elected Senate would probably require a party system. The Liberals have committed to the opposite. And if it’s not going to be elected, the other reforms I’d like to see don’t make sense. They only work as a package. So I’m left with abolition, or the tweaked status quo.

The status quo works for the interim, but it's not a long-term solution to Senate reform. If the long-term choice is a Senate providing sober second thought to Commons legislation -- on a partisan basis or not -- or abolition, I’d say abolish it.

The more I think about it, the more I agree it is about partisanship. But not (just) partisanship in the Senate – partisanship in the House of Commons. We wouldn’t need sober second thought if MPs were providing sober first thought, but the choking yoke of party discipline has made that impossible. With more independence for MPs within the party system – freedom to amend legislation, free votes requiring compromise to bring MPs onside, even within parties -- the Commons could get it right the first time.

If MPs were free to do their intended jobs – scrutinize and consider government legislation – we wouldn’t need the Senate for sober second though. I’d still argue for a reformed, regionally-balanced Senate to balance off the rep by pop will of the house, but not if they’re un-elected.

So that’s why I ask, what’s next? The Liberals have seized the day today.  I wonder, though, about the Senate’s tomorrow.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

Harper’s credibility, the evening news and life outside the Commons

The mistake many politically aware and involved people make is believing everyone follows the ins and outs of every political development as much as they do. They don’t. People are busy. They have other priorities. Believing that everyone shares their anger is a mistake partisans too routinely make.

Most Canadians, for example, don’t watch Power and Politics or Question Period (sorry Evan and Don). Many of them do, however, watch their local evening news. What my extended family knows about current events, they get there. Myself, I watch CTV Toronto’s 6pm newscast most nights, having long ago resigned myself to the fact I live in Toronto and so I may as well learn what’s going on here.

And last night, for the first time I can remember outside a general election, federal politics led the newscast. CTV News at Six did four minutes on the day’s developments on the Senate front, and it wasn’t positive for Prime Minister Harper. The focus was on Mike Duffy’s speech, documents and allegations about the Harper PMO, with a mention of Harper’s evolving language on Wright (from resigned to dismissed) thrown in for good measure.

As I tweeted last night, that’s a broadcast that real people watch. And the report went directly to what has been a Harper strength with Canadians: leadership and competence. Step outside the bubble and what do most Canadians think of the Prime Minister? Not overly warm, but a competent manager and a strong leader that runs a tight ship. The Conservatives have played to this for years, branding successive Liberal leaders as “not a leader” and weak or in over their hands in comparison to Harper’s strong leadership as a beacon in troubled times.

The Senate affair is particularly worrying for the Conservatives (prompting Harper’s Mad As Hell radio tour) because it chips at those very strengths. It shows him as either unaware of what’s going on in his office or complicit in the very sort of unethical behavior he was elected to eliminate, as willing to write cheques to make problems go away and, increasingly, as unable to keep Conservative Senators, MPs and others in line, as they increasingly go off the script he has tried to set. Harper is the common thread -- he hired Nigel Wright, he appointed Duffy, Pamela Wallin and Patrick Brazeau, his office is at the centre of it all.

He once ran ads alleging Stephane Dion wasn’t a leader because Liberal senators were acting independently – now even the former Conservative Party president, Senator Don Plett, is bucking under the Harper whip. When you sell yourself as a strong leader, it's hard to claim ignorance of what's happening around you.

Most people won’t look at it that in-depth. What they will get, though, is the impression that maybe Harper isn’t much of a leader after all. Maybe he’s not as ethical as he says. No one scandal can flip the impressions that people have, but they can plant seeds.

It’s too early to say what the lasting impact, if any, of this affair will be. However, the drip drip of scandal is cumulative. The Harper Conservatives have weathered many storms, some bigger and more important than others, from Afghan Detainees and contempt of Parliament to prorogation, robocalls and in and out. None will shift impressions on their own. But each nudges the needle, and germinate the seeds planted from earlier incidents. Eventually, new narratives begin to form.

Even then, new impressions don’t necessarily prove fatal. At best, people will become open to considering alternatives. For the government to pay a price, and for the opposition parties to be in a position to benefit, there has to be credible alternatives for them to consider. One reason Conservatives haven’t paid the price that some partisans felt they should for past scandals is that Canadians weren’t enamored of their alternatives. Sometimes, it’s better the devil you know.

The gallery and partisans tend to focus on the House of Commons and the melodrama of question period. But that’s the bubble. Canadians don’t watch question period. At best, they might see a few seconds in a clip on the evening news. They don’t care who is best at cross-examining Harper. The next election will not be won in the House of Commons.

The next election will be won in church basements, Legion halls and coffee shops across Canada. After the Conservatives lost in 2004, Harper planted the seeds for victory in 2006 with an extensive cross-country tour. The Commons is important and shouldn’t be ignored, but it’s not the real battleground.

The Senate scandal may cause Canadians to once again examine their alternatives. And what they’ll be looking for hasn’t changed: they want leadership that understands their challenges and shares their priorities. Scandal will come and go, but we should see the forest for the trees. Building that alternative must be our real and enduring focus.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Thursday, August 01, 2013

Even if it could, Senate reform shouldn’t proceed without the provinces – or the people

To the surprise of everyone in the Ottawa bubble, Her Majesty’s Minister of State for Democratic Reform, Pierre Poilievre, held a press availability Wednesday not to slam the Liberals for some alleged sins, but to actually speak to an issue of policy substance: the government’s Supreme Court reference on Senate reform.

The minister discussed the factum the government has presented to the court outlining its position, marking the first time the words “Pierre Poilievre” and “factum” have appeared in the same sentence. The government has put several questions to the court, essentially seeking clarity around what reforms Parliament can make on its own, what reforms would require provincial approval, and what level of provincial approval would be required for outright abolition, ie. unanimity, or seven provinces with half the population.

The Harper government’s position is that it can proceed unilaterally on Senate reform. I’m not a legal expert, but most of those I’ve seen weigh-in say, while it can proceed unilaterally in some ways, substantive reform does mean constitutional reform. And while the feds can make some changes to areas of sole federal interest on its own, substantive reforms would likely go beyond that.

But I’ll let the legal experts, and of course the Supreme Court, hash that one out. There’s what’s legal, and what’s right. And even if the courts said the feds could substantively reform or even abolish the Senate without the provinces, I’d argue they lack the moral authority to do so and would be making a mistake if they tried.

I’ve written extensively on the Senate in the past. Most recently I’ve argued what I’d like the Senate to be – an upper chamber with equal representation by province or region with clearly defined powers, to serve as a regional counter-weight to what should be a purely representation by population lower chamber in the House of Commons. With uneven population growth across the country, I think that’s an important piece to have in our parliament. The provinces have an undeniable interest in ensuring regional voices are heard and represented fairly in parliament; it’s difficult to argue this is purely a federal matter.

However, I would go beyond just requiring provincial approval through the amending formula for substantive Senate reform or unanimity for abolition. The people must be involved too. When Stephen Harper first came to Ottawa as a staffer and later a Reform MP in 1993, he was a leader in a party that believed in consulting the people on such matters via referendum. It’s time he returned to his roots.

Before we proceed down the road to reforming or abolishing the Senate, which would be a pretty major change to our democracy, the people must become involved. We need to have a debate in this country around how we want to be represented, and what we want our democracy and our parliament to look like.
And then we should vote in a national referendum, and the federal and provincial governments should proceed as the people direct.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Thursday, May 30, 2013

There is an argument for the Senate – just not this Senate, or this House of Commons

The Senate has been much in the news lately, with the expense troubles of a few Senators – compounded by the mishandling of their investigation – bringing much  negative attention to the other place. While this is really a scandal about Stephen Harper’s decision-making and the style of governance he fosters, a serious and real national debate about the Senate’s place in our democracy is long overdue.

It’s easy to look at the shenanigans and say just abolish the thing. The NDP wasted little time in making that case. I think the misdoings of a few Senators is a poor argument for abolishing the thing. However, the NDP are long-standing abolitionists and, while I disagree for reasons I’ll outline shortly, I credit them for their consistency on the issue. Some of the provinces have also begun making pro-abolition musings. Some Conservatives too, although the official party position – in spite of their utter lack of substantive progress towards it – is to reform the Senate to be at least elected and effective; I’m not sure about the equal.

The Liberal position on the Senate has always been a bit more difficult to pin down, other than, of course, preferring we be the ones doing the appointing. From what I can gather, we’re lukewarm on elections, fine with term limits, and (rightly) believe real reform requires constitutional amendment – which we’re not keen on doing. The latter issue has been referred by the government to the Supreme Court for an opinion; I think the answer is fairly obvious, but we’ll see what they say. Stéphane Dion Dion has also done some interesting work in this area.

While abolition is an easy and populist argument to make, there is a case to be made for keeping the Senate. I don’t think I’ve heard it made yet, though.

I want us to keep the Senate. Just not this Senate. Let me make this clear: I’m arguing for a substantively reformed Senate, not the status quo. With respect to all the fine reports, hearings and second thought the upper chamber provides today, it’s not enough to justify its existence in its current form.

In any democracy with a bicameral system, the two houses are meant to each serve separate and distinct purposes. The lower chamber, our House of Commons, is meant to be the people’s house, pure representation by population. This would mean areas with more people get more seats, and more populous regions would have more representation. The purest form of democracy, but in a geographically diverse country with divergent regional interests, there’s potential for important perspectives not to be heard. Which is where the upper chamber – our Senate – is supposed to come in: as a body with representation equally allotted not by population but by region, providing a regional counterbalance to the rep by pop voice of the lower chamber.

Problem is, neither chambers fill those roles today. For the House of Commons, just look at the last round of seat redistribution. Instead of proportioning seats purely on population, politics meant faster growing regions remained somewhat under-represented, Quebec still had to be kept at a certain level, and seats were added because taking away seats from any area was deemed politically unacceptable.

And then there’s the Senate. With a formula based on how Canada looked closer to Confederation than today, the regional balance is out of whack. The Maritimes are over-represented; the West under-represented. It’s also unelected, which, frankly, is a positive right now because, without a regional rebalancing and a revision of the powers of the Senate – if we elected Senators today and gave them a democratic mandate, gridlock could ensue, and the West would be greatly disadvantaged. Without a democratic mandate today, Senators rightly exercise just a fraction of their constitutional authority.

I’d favour abolition over the status quo. Abolition would still, though, require a constitutional amendment and probably provincial negotiation. So before we decide between abolition and reform, the question we need to ask is, in an ideal world, do we want a true bicameral system, and is a regional check on the rep by pop power of the Commons desirable?

I think, in a country like Canada, that regional check is essential. The perspectives of the West, of Quebec, of the Maritimes, and of Ontario, are often unique and different. A properly-constituted Senate would ensure that, as laws are made and the future of our country charted, these perspectives are heard.

And if we’re going to be doing the constitutional thing anyway, I’d rather fix our democracy and get this thing right.  So, as part of such a process, here’s a few things I’d like to see:

  • An overhaul of representation in the House of Commons, including a reviewable cap on the number of MPs and the proportioning of seats purely on population, moving seats from declining-population areas to higher-population areas.
  • An elected Senate, with set terms and an end to the archaic constitutional requirements for a minimum age and land ownership. Also, rebalancing representation so Senate seats are allotted equally by region.
  • A revision of the powers and role of the Senate. It should be effective in reviewing and proposing legislation, and curbing the excesses of the House, but to avoid gridlock there should be a mechanism for the House to over-turn a Senate move to over-rule it if a certain threshold of support (say, two-thirds) can be achieved.

Getting to such a model may not be possible. It would require a great deal of negotiation among competing federal and provincial interests, not to mention Indigenous and municipal. There would need to be a great deal of give and take, and getting the balance right would be difficult. The temptation would be to widen the scope of the constitutional negotiation, which would be a mistake – history shows focus in these things is important.

Let’s remember though, abolition would also be difficult. It’s not as easy as waving a magic wand. Provincial support (and likely a referendum) would also be required for an abolition constitutional amendment, and the same competing interests would need to be satisfied.

If we’re increasingly agreed though that blithely accepting the status quo because change is difficult is no longer acceptable, then change becomes inevitable. The only question is, what change. It’s time we had a national debate about what that change should be.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Friday, May 25, 2012

Great event with Stephane Dion in Toronto on Saturday

If you're in Toronto on Saturday (May 26th) this is where you should be, as the Edward Blake Society presents a pub night and discussion on Canadian democracy and reform with former Liberal leader (and still number one in my heart) Stephane Dion.

It begins at 6pm at Pauper's Pub, 539 Bloor Street West (at Bathurst) in Toronto. He'll speak about the Senate, seat redistribution and electoral reform, with plenty of time for questions. Hope you can make it out, as it should be a great event.


Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Wednesday, October 05, 2011

Stéphane Dion on senate reform

I've long argued that the Conservative strategy on Senate reform is deeply flawed, and bad for both Western Canada and effective governance.


With debate underway on the latest Conservative Senate reform bill, one that seems destined to pass given their majority in the House and their numbers in the Senate, I was pleased to read Stéphane Dion's speech and remarks on the issue during the Commons debates as the Liberal intergovernmental affairs critic.

You can read the full comments here, or in the Hansard (starting around 1305) but here's an excerpt:
Madam Speaker, the Liberal Party does not oppose Senate reform, but it must be done right and in accordance with the Constitution.

There are three reasons the Liberal opposition cannot support the bill.

First, it is the conviction of the Liberal opposition that such an act would be unconstitutional. The fundamental changes it proposes cannot be implemented by Parliament alone. These changes would require the support of at least seven provinces, representing 50% of the Canadian population, notably because appointing senators through a patchwork of voluntary provincial senatorial elections is clearly a fundamental change; limiting the senators' tenure to nine years is a significant change; and giving the Prime Minister the power to name the totality of senators at the end of two mandates of four and a half years would strengthen his power considerably, another significant change.

Second, such an act would be against the interests of two of our provinces, Alberta and British Columbia. Here is why: practically speaking, an elected upper chamber would carry more weight in its dealings with the House of Commons than it does in its present form. The problem is that both western provinces are better represented in the House than they are in the Senate, and both provinces have only six senators, while some provinces have 10 with a population four or six times smaller.

Third, such an act could provoke frequent blockages in Parliament in the absence of a constitutional mechanism to resolve any conflicts that might arise between an elected House of Commons and an elected Senate.
I have to say I agree with every point that Dion made, and not just because I've made them all many times myself, if not quite as eloquently. But he also made one very interesting point that hadn't occurred to me before either:
It is important to realize that the government's muddled plan would have senators appointed through a patchwork system of optional provincial elections. Funding for these federal elections would come from the provinces, and even though they would be federal elections, the federal parties would be excluded from the electoral process. The provincial parties would control these federal elections. What a mess.
It's hardly the worst part of the Conservative plan, but it is an interesting wrinkle: no federal parties could officially participate in this system as envisioned. What would this do for spending limits, for example, and fundraising? Would it create an uneven playing field for Senators accross different provinces?

And it underscores another weakness: the Harper plan asks the provinces to undertake and fund elections to determine representation to a federal parliamentary chamber. We've known that all along but the more you think about it, the less sense it makes. You wouldn't propose the same for the House of Commons, would you?

It comes down to the same point I've been making all along: this piecework reform is a bad idea. if you want to reform the Senate, truly reform it. Hold takes with the provinces and open the constitution to do full-scale reform. Elected Senators through a federal process, equal regional representation, and clearly defined and limited responsibilities and/or a mechanism to avoid legislative gridlock between the legislative chambers. Or just abolish it. You can make a case for either, but I do feel a Senate based on equal regional representation as a stop on a rep by pop-based Commons has merit.

But as Dion argues, this patch-work, half-hearted pseudo reform is actually worse than real reform, particularly for Western Canada. Do we really want a Senate that will actually use its constitutionally mandated powers but with BC and Alberta vastly under-represented?

I wonder if the Conservative base out West will ever figure this out.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Will anyone stand-up for equality of parliamentary representation?

With our parliamentarians having returned to Ottawa this week, it seems appropriate to turn our attention to just how our parliament is composed. Representation in the House of Commons is sure to be a contentious issue once again, and I’m having a hard time finding a sensible position from any of the parties.

I won’t rehash all the background – long story short, representation in the lower house is supposed to be by population, but population shifts across the country over the years mean the current house isn’t truly representative of today’s Canada. Suburban/urban areas in British Columbia, Alberta are extremely under-represented.

The Conservatives have had a proposal on the table for several years to add 30 seats (five in Alberta, seven in B.C. and 18 in Ontario) that would make some progress toward more representative representation. It has gone through some modifications following complaints from various quarters, and they haven’t been in much of a hurry to move forward with it. Indeed, they seemed to agree with the other parties in the last parliament to quietly shelve it until after the election – none of them wanted the issue floating around during a campaign.

Why? That’s the heart of the issue: it’s all about Quebec. Any other province would accept their population doesn’t warrant more seats but, for Quebec, it’s a “national unity” issue. With other regions growing, they see their influence in the House of Common declining. And they’re demanding artificial measures (extra seats not warranted by population) in recognition of their “special” status. The most common ask: a guaranteed floor of 25 per cent of HoC seats, regardless of population.

It’s called the Senate

I strongly disagree with this. Representation in the House of Commons should be by population, period. Giving one region unequal weighting would mean taking representation from another region; that’s unfair and that’s not the purpose of the lower chamber.

Do I agree that Quebec has a unique perspective? Yes. And I believe the Maritimes, Ontario, Western Canada and British Columbia do too. And the territories. And I believe having a regional bulkwark to a pure rep by pop system that gives Ontario a very large voice is important and desirable.

And we already have a body designed to provide (in theory) that regional check: It’s called the Senate. The lower house is intended as the representative house; the upper the regional check.

Now the Senate is in need of reform and redistribution as well. But if you want to build a truly effective and representative parliamentary democracy, gerrymandering commons representation isn’t the answer. Reform the Senate so it is fairly distributed along regional lines, with elected Senators who have a clear mandate and set of powers and responsibilities.

About those Commons seats

Now, I won’t hold my breath for any of the political parties to start advocating comprehensive and meaningful Senate reform. And sorry, what the Conservatives have been doing here has been hurting, not helping.

I’d be more hopeful of someone taking a logical position on Commons representation though. Sadly, no such luck so far.

There’s some hope in the Conservative position. It could go further, but it’s a step in the right direction. While they’ve disavowed special considerations for Quebec, as mentioned they’ve shown no hurry to move forward with actual legislation either.

My Liberals have been hard to pin down. Before the election they helped to delay the proposal, and splits were evident between their Quebec caucus and the rest of the members. After the election? Interim leader Bob Rae gave an interview that left me puzzled.

(Rae) predicted that the prime minister will come up with a compromise on the seat legislation bill to deal with Quebec's concerns.

"I don't think you can take Quebec for granted, and I think the prime minister's going to have to look again at the question of the number of Quebec seats. It doesn't mean B.C., Alberta and Ontario won't get more seats - of course we will."

OK, so he wants special dispensation for Quebec?

Rae wouldn't say whether or not he supports the position of many Quebec nationalists that the province should be guaranteed 25 per cent of the seats.

So compromise if necessary, but not necessarily that compromise? OK, but what then? After all, this is about national unity, somehow.

With their new large Quebec caucus, the NDP has been a little more clear on its position: special seats for Quebec.

(Brian Topp) giving extra seats to Quebec would be a way to recognize its status as a nation within Canada.

"I think we need to find an appropriate Canadian compromise," he said at a news conference announcing his candidacy.

And the guy that may not run:

The NDP has argued that Quebec should be guaranteed to maintain its current share of the seats. That would require the 338-seat Commons to be swollen further by boosting Quebec's allotment to 82 or 83 seats, from the current 75.

Earlier Monday, Mulcair told reporters that such a move is consistent with the 2006 "nation" motion and the 1991 Supreme Court of Canada decision.

"It would be an irony to say that Quebec constitutes — the Quebecois constitute — a nation within Canada and then the first thing you do is you reduce the . . . weight of Quebecers within the House of Commons."

Nation reflux disease

There is a certain irony that many of the arguments being made come back to the Quebec nation resolution of 2006, hailed at the time as a master-stroke of strategic genius by Prime Minister Harper. My worry then was that you can say it’s just symbolism, but empty symbolism isn’t going to satisfy anyone; eventually they’ll want something real. Now those chickens are coming home to roost: the Quebec nationalists want some meat on that nation bone we gave them. The question is what happens if they don’t get it?

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Monday, May 30, 2011

Senate reform shouldn’t be a populist bandwagon of convenience

Following Stephen Harper’s appointment of several (more) failed Conservative candidates to the Senate, we’ve seen the usual outrage over the sheer contempt demonstrated by the moves. But for those who say Harper is trying to (semi) reform the upper chamber by bringing it into disrepute, some evidence is also emerging there may be some method to his madness.

In Newfoundland, where Fabian Manning’s move from Harper Senator to candidate rejected at the polls this week back to Harper Senator has raised hackles, the Liberal opposition leader is suddenly calling for Senate elections:

Newfoundland and Labrador should elect its first senator this fall, the province's opposition leader said Wednesday. "All it would take to elect a senator would be an extra ballot for voters to mark when they vote in this fall's provincial election," Liberal leader Yvonne Jones said in a news release.

The province’s Conservative Premier, incidentally, isn’t a fan of the idea.

And closer to home in Ontario, I’m hearing rumours Dalton McGuinty’s provincial Liberal government may add a Senate election to this fall’s scheduled provincial elections.

I must say, I’m skeptical of this sudden interest in Senate elections by two provincial Liberal parties. Given that I don’t recall this being a topic of discussion in these circles before, I’d have to guess the fact the federal Liberals are in the wilderness and won’t be wielding the power of appointment any time soon may have something to do with it.

More so, though, this seems to me to be a knee-jerk reaction to Harper’s provocations with these latest appointments. Jones and McGuinty may see this as a chance to jump on a populist bandwagon by pushing for Senate elections, hoping a populist wave may raise their own boats at the polls this fall.

Whether their political calculus is accurate or not, it’s a short-sighted move that would be bad for public policy and regional representation at the federal level. And, I suspect, it would play into Harper’s hands. Even if a Liberal senator may get elected in one of these elections (small risk in Ontario, I’d say, but maybe not in Newfoundland) and he’d have to appoint them, I think Harper would see it as a small price to pay for moving toward an elected senate giving him a victory on his version of Senate reform.

As I’ve written many times, Harper’s piecemeal Senate reform plan is dangerous. Electing Senators gives them legitimacy and the mandate to exercise their power.

  • We shouldn’t take that step until we consider just what we want Senators to do – how are they different from MPs and what should their legislative role be?
  • The current Senate composition also severely under-represents British Columbia. We need to fix the regional balance of the Senate before giving it real power and the legitimacy of elected members; otherwise we’re entrenching the unfair treatment of the West.
  • A Senate with a mix of elected members exercising their constitutional powers and appointed members not exercising those powers would be a mess.

Meaningful Senate reform would require constitutional amendment, an option the Conservatives have shown no interest in entertaining. Their piecemeal reforms are designed to give the appearance of reform but major planks, such as term limits, are likely wouldn’t survive a court challenge. It’s all just for show.

If we want to debate Senate reform we should do it full-hog. Until then, I support maintaining the status quo. Which means Harper can appoint whomever he wants, and if we object we can vote against him in four years.

In the interim, I’d urge my provincial cousins not to put populist calculations and provincial electoral expediency ahead of the future of the red chamber; gaining a few points of support provincially isn’t worth saddling us with a dysfunctional and disfigured yet powerful Senate. They need to look at the big picture.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Wednesday, January 05, 2011

What do merit pay, a carbon tax and Tommy Chong have in common?

Out to British Columbia again, where the candidates for the leadership of the BC Liberal Party have been busy lately talking policy ideas.

Kevin Falcon took a controversial position this week when he argued for merit pay for teachers and cash incentives for schools and teachers that improve test scores.

If he wins the leadership contest next month, Falcon said he would create a master teacher incentive program that would recognize exceptional and innovative educators and a model school incentive program that would reward schools for improvements in student achievement.

…his plan wouldn't rely solely on test scores. Rather, he said his government would work with teachers, administrators, parents and community leaders to develop criteria for identifying innovative educators.

Falcon’s proposal sparked a firestorm of criticism. The BC Teachers Federation, predictably, called it “a cockamamie notion” and his leadership opponent, former education minister George Abbott, said it would amount to cherry-picking one element of failed U.S. experiments in education.

Mr. Abbott said he was opposed to throwing “one experimental or trick shot piece out there that is drawn from the American experience and may not be applicable to our experience,” into education policy in this province.

Still no word, by the way, on Falcon's flip-flop on lowering the voting age from 18 to 16.

Abbott made his own major policy push yesterday, and it wasn’t without its own controversial policy positions. For example, remember the carbon tax? While it helped fell Stephane Dion, BC’s own carbon tax, while controversial at its inception, remains quietly in place in BC. The BC Liberals won the last election despite a concerted effort by the BC NDP to defeat them on the carbon tax. Still, Abbott wants to revive the issue with a referendum:

The carbon tax referendum would be held June 24, which is also the date Abbott proposes for bringing forward the provincewide vote (currently set for Sept. 24) on whether to extinguish the harmonized sales tax.

Abbott said many British Columbians are rightly proud of the trail blazing carbon tax, which is scheduled to climb to seven cents a litre effective July 1, 2012. But he questioned whether the province should continue with such a tax when, as he put it, "the rest of North American is not dancing with us on this issue."

So, rather that being an environmental leader and continuing with a carbon tax, the system increasingly favoured not just by environmentalists but even by the energy industry, Abbott wants to re-open the can of worms? It’s an absolutely horrible idea. I can only surmise he seems some political advantage if he can rile up people on the issue, but it’s both bad policy and bad politics in my view. It is (was) a dead issue. I agree with Falcon on this one:

But Falcon rejected Abbott's call for a referendum, saying, "we had a referendum on the carbon tax and it was called the general election."

While it didn’t get the attention of merit pay for teachers or a carbon tax referendum, I was more disturbed by Abbott’s senate musings:

He also said the province should follow the route of Alberta and begin electing senate nominees.

When one of B.C.'s six seats in the Canadian Senate becomes vacant, a provincewide election would be held. The winner's name would then be forwarded to the prime minister for appointment to fill the vacancy.

Sounds nice in theory, but in reality it’s bad for the Senate and bad for British Columbia. I’ve blogged about this at length in the past, but in short, BC is very ill-served by the current composition of the Senate.

While the Commons is representation by population (in theory), the Senate is meant to balance that with representation by region. The problem is, the current regional make-up of the Senate is outdated, and is based on a 19th century view of confederation-era Canada. The Maratimes are vastly over represented. Dido Upper and Lower Canada. The West, meanwhile, is lumped together as one regional group.

This inequity, while grating, is less pressing while the Senate is composed of unelected sober second thoughters that, recognizing their constitutional illegitimacy, are loathe (well, usually loathe) to circumvent the will of the elected Commons.

However, if you elect senators as Harper and Abbott favour, then those elected senators will be able to claim a democratic mandate and will not hesitate to exercise their not insubstantial constitutional powers.

Creating elected senators without addressing the regional composition of the Senate and addressing the balance of powers between the house of parliament is a bad idea, and it’s bad for BC. I’ll say to Abbott what I’ve long said (well, blogged) to Harper: you shouldn’t do senate reform half-assed. It has to be all or nothing.

Meanwhile, Christy Clark yesterday launched a series of open government initiatives aimed at increasing public confidence and public participation in the democratic process. It included a promise to, as Premier, hold a dozen town halls each year with BC residents.

“The reality is that voters feel a disconnect with their government,” said the former deputy premier and education minister.

“These proposals are designed to reconnect people with government.”

Other proposals put forward by Ms.Clark include working with all MLAs to see more private members’ bills debated and passed as well as a caucus accountability committee with the party leader as member, and cabinet accountability sessions in the regions of B.C. at regional policy conferences or other special events.
More on the specific proposals is available here. Some are more ambitious than others, but I like the monthly townhalls and more streaming video of legislative and committee meetings.

As for the BC NDP

While I don’t agree with all of their ideas, I have been impressed with the level of policy-focused debate we’ve seen in the BC Liberal leadership race. Meanwhile, over on the BC NDP side, Dana Larsen remains the only declared candidate. He has, however, secured a key endorsement:

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Monday, December 20, 2010

Another Conservative rejected by voters appointed a Harper Senator

Stephen Harper once vowed he would only appoint elected senators. We're obviously long past that point for assorted reasons, some valid and some not as much, but what is impressive is how far in the other direction the Harper Conservatives have gone.

Never mind appointing only elected senators. We're so far removed from the spirit of that pledge that Harper has now made a habit of appointing to patronage heaven people who, when they were on the ballot, were rejected by the electorate. Instead of elected senators, we have senators who couldn't get elected.

The latest, called to the senate today, is Don Meredith. The failed Conservative candidate in the Toronto-Centre by-election in 2008 won by Liberal Bob Rae, Meredith finished not second, and not third, but fourth in that by-election, with just 2,982 votes for a paltry 12.5 per cent of the vote. Not only was Meredith behind the NDP, Green Party candidate Chris Tindal finished ahead of Meredith, besting him by 281 votes.

How bad was it for Meredith? Even the former Conservative candidate in the riding (later dumped by CPC HQ), Mark Warner, endorsed Rae:

On March 10, Warner publicly endorsed Rae, the man he’d planned to run against. (A breaking point for him was Meredith telling a St. James Town crowd that bedbugs were a matter of hygiene. “Telling your potential constituents ‘you stink, you don’t wash, you live in filth’ probably isn’t the best way to win an election,” Warner says.)
While Meredith did manage to score better than the candidates for the Animal Alliance and the Canadian Action Party, the message was pretty clear from Toronto-Centre voters they didn't want Meredith as their MP. But now he'll represent all of Ontario in the senate.

In case you think Meredith is an isolated case, by my count Meredith is the 10th senator appointed by Harper who ran for office and was rejected by the electorate. I wrote about all of them in a previous post; the list includes Salma Ataullahjan, Yonah Martin, Claude Carignan, Fabian Manning, Michel Rivard, John Wallace, Leo Houskas, Michael Fortier and Suzanne Duplessis.

Having to appoint senators in the absence of senate reform is one thing (we'll save the conversation about Harper's utter aversion to meaningful senate reform for another day). But claiming to favour an elected senate for accountability purposes, and then making a habit of appointed people who have been rejected by the electorate, is quite another.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Friday, July 09, 2010

Harper’s road to an elected Senate: Appoint Conservatives that can't get elected

I’ve long held that when it comes to his supposed commitment to Senate reform, Stephen Harper is a fraud. The mountain of evidence is so overwhelming it seems almost churlish to point-out more examples. Still, churlishness is mandatory for bloggers, so I shall forge ahead and do just that.

Today, Stephen Harper asked Her Majesty to call to the Senate one Salma Ataullahjan, to fill a vacancy in Ontario. I know little about Ms. Ataullahjan. I wish her the best, and I hope she serves the people of Ontario ably and well.

The only think I do know about her is that she was a Conservative candidate in the 2008 election, where she was rejected by the voters of Mississauga-Brampton South in favour of Liberal MP Navdeep Bains.

And Ataullahjan is far from the only failed Conservative candidate from the 2008 election to be called up to patronage heaven. Far from the only one indeed.

Senator Yonah Martin ran in New Westminster—Coquitlam and lost to the NDP’s Dawn Black.

Senator Claude Carignan ran in Rivière-des-Mille-Îles and got whooped by the BQ’s Luc Desnoyers.

Senator Fabian Manning lost in Avalon to Danny Williams, er, Liberal Scott Andrews.

And that’s just Conservative senators that were rejected by the electorate in the 2008 election. Stephen “I want elected Senators” Harper has sent many people to the Senate that have failed to get elected.

Senator Michel Rivard ran for the Canadian Alliance in the riding of Québec in 2000, losing to the BQ’s Christiane Gagnon.

Senator John Wallace ran in Saint John in 2006, losing to Liberal Paul Zed.

Here’s a fun one. The 2000 election in the riding of Laval West featured two future Harper Senators, both of whom lost. The Canadian Alliance candidate was Leo Houskas, a Harper fundraiser called to the Senate in 2009. And the Progressive Conservative candidate was Michael Fortier, infamously called to the Senate and cabinet following the 2005/06 election. Both of them lost to Liberal Raymonde Falco as the voters said non, merci to both future Senators. Fortier, of course, resigned from the Senate to again run to be the MP for Vaudreuil-Soulanges, and once again was rejected by the electorate, losing to the BQ’s Meili Faille.

And finally (have I missed anyone?) let’s not forget Senator Suzanne Duplessis, rejected as a Progressive Conservative by the voters of Louis-Hébert in favour of the BQ’s Philippe Paré in 1993.

You ask, dear reader, what’s my point? It’s this: how can someone who professes to believe that electing Senators is a democratic imperative (that would be Stephen Harper) be taken seriously when they keep appointing Senators that, when they were on the ballot, were rejected by the voters? The answer, of course is no, they can’t be taken seriously at all.

Look, for the record I’m not a fan of electing Senators. If you want to mess around with the Senate, I say just abolish the thing. Failing that, I’d support elected Senators but only as part of a wider constitutional-based reform that also looks at regional representation and the balance of powers between the House and the Senate. Otherwise, under the status quo I’m fine with appointing learned and respected people that perhaps couldn’t get elected normally, but bring a needed voice and perspective to the chamber.

Stephen Harper, however, does pretend to be a supporter of electing Senators. Which is why it’s ridiculous for him to habitually appoint Senators who, when their names were on a ballot and the voters had a chance to elect them, were rejected.

Like all of Harper’s supposed Senate reform principles, it’s a farce. Like the supposed commitment of his appointees to term limits and supporting an elected Senate – once appointed, they’re changing their minds. And since the "commitments" are unenforceable, there's jack squat he can do. (Except boot them from caucus, which he hasn't bothered to do.) Like the piecemeal reform legislation he keeps pushing is bad for the country and possibly unconstitutional. And like his unwillingness to do what it would really take to reform the Senate – open the constitution.

If anyone still believes Stephen Harper is serious about Senate reform they’re either gullible, deluded, or just plain lying.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Thursday, October 08, 2009

Crime and the Senate

Reading news coverage this morning leaves me pondering just what role many media and politicians expect the Senate to play in our democracy and whether, all things considered, blowing the thing up may just make more sense.

I’ve read many headlines this morning alleging that Liberal senators are “gutting” the latest Conservative pander/get tough on crime legislation: the bill dealing with ending the 2-for-1 credit for pre-sentencing confinement.

In short (or not), every day served in jail before someone is actually convicted counts as two days off the sentence they’re given, the thinking being they hadn’t been found guilty of anything yet, and it’s the poor that are more likely to be confined pre-conviction because they can’t afford to make bail.

The Conservatives proposed legislation to end the 2-for-1 credit, and make one day count as, well, one day. They say defense attorneys are abusing the system by dragging-out cases to maximize the pre-conviction credit, and, rawrr, the time sentenced should be the time done. It received all-party support and then went to the Senate, where the drama began.

The Senate heard from expert witnesses who said the bill was unconstitutional. The Senate decided to amend the bill to 1.5 days credit for pre-sentencing time, with judicial discretion for 2 days. The bill is expected to the House, where the Senate changes can be over-ruled and the legislation reverted to its original form.

This has triggered much predictable braying from the Conservatives, with the NDP jumping-in with their Conservative friends for good measure. Unelected Senators shouldn’t change House legislation, they complain. The Liberal Senators are soft on crime, they bellow. Oh, and Michael Ignatieff is a weak leader because Liberal Senators don’t do exactly what he says.

I don’t want to debate the merits of the legislation at the moment. Rather, I want to look at what this episode says about the role we expect the Senate to play in our democratic system. Because, like it or not, what the Senate did here is exactly what it is supposed to do: it examined the legislation, heard from learned witnesses, considered their concerns, and made amendments.

The House has the right to over-rule them, and it probably will but the Senate didn’t overstep its bounds at all. It did its job: sober second thought.

Then there’s the attacks on Ignatieff’s leadership here: are we really saying that the party leader should insist on rigid discipline and party-line votes from its Senators on every piece of legislation? That doesn’t make sense, it’s not how the system has worked or is meant to work.

And if the Senate is to be a party-line institution, a do whatever the House says institution that can’t amend legislation, why the heck would we keep it around anyway?

Only the NDP supports abolition, Harper supposedly want to reform the Senate. One wonders, to what end, though? If it was elected Liberal senators amending his legislation, would he find that more legitimate? I find that unlikely. Is he going to expect every elected Conservative Senator to toe his party line, or might they have other ideas about the role of an elected, equal and effective Senate?

And, while I do favour Senate reform and while I don’t want to sidetrack into a debate on the merits of this particular crime legislation, let me just say that this could well be a case-study for why the Senate is here.

You have a house of elected MPs who are so dammed scared of the “soft on crime” label that they often let their better judgment be swayed by political considerations. As a check and balance we have a Senate, the chamber of sober second thought that, not having to fight for election seemingly every year, is free to listen to experts, consider legislation on its merits, and made decisions based on facts, not political positioning.

Unelected as they may be, that freedom at times seems like a pretty good thing. Would six-year terms for Senators help achieve that for elected Senators? Perhaps. But that freedom is certainly something worth preserving somehow, in my view.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Saturday, August 29, 2009

If Harper really wanted to reform the Senate, I’d get on board

Reading Stephen Harper’s defence to criticism of his appointment of a slew of his close associates and cronies to the Senate, and a number of editorials from that dastardly Liberal media defending his orgy of pork, the main justification seems to be this: If he wants to reform the Senate, he has no choice but to stuff it with Conservative hacks.

That’s complete nonsense. With apologies to Brian Mulroney, I say this to Stephen: You did have a choice, sir! You could actually make a serious effort to reform the Senate.

You see, I support Senate reform. I’m just not sure Stephen Harper does. Oh, sure, he likes it as an issue. It plays well with his base to rail against the evil, unelected Senate. And the Senate is a handy bogeyman for him to blame his assorted inadequacies and short-comings on. Par example, after refusing Liberal offers to fast-track the bulk of his crime legislation, he finally gets it though the House. Then , after the Senate has it for less than a week, he accuses them of obstructionism. When legislation dies on the order paper because he prorogues parliament to avoid defeat, he blames the Senate. When the Senate wants to actually do its job of sober second though and not rubber-stamp bills in a day, well, you get the idea.

No, when it comes to reforming the Senate, Harper seems to be content to nibble around the edges. Sure, if a province elects someone, he’ll appoint them. Of course, Saskatchewan was on that road when he appointed Pamela Wallin. And he’ll make them promise to serve only eight years (it will be interesting to see if Doug Finley steps aside in eight years if the Liberals are in government and making appointments, won’t it?) And he’s half-heartedly tried to push a bill mandating term-limits, a bill the experts agree is unconstitutional.

As someone who wants real Senate reform, I actually find Harper’s nibbling around the edges dangerous, both to our democracy and to the cause of meaningful Senate reform. That’s because creating a mix of elected and unelected Senators, and electing Senators without addressing the balance of powers between the House of Commons and the Senate, and the inequities that currently exist around a lack of regional balance, is fraught with trouble.

Constitutionally, the Senate is nearly equal to the House of Commons in its powers. However, recognizing that as an unelected body it lacks the legitimacy to block the will of the elected House, it traditionally doesn’t exercise that power, contenting itself to examine legislation and investigate issues but largely respect the will of the lower house.

But in a Senate of elected Senators, who in theory can claim a legitimacy and a mandate of their own, what’s to prevent them from using that power? What if one party has a majority in the House and another party a majority in an elected Senate? You could have actual gridlock, not the fake gridlock Harper kvetches about today.

I also see problems in a Senate of mixed elected and appointed senators, some claiming the legitimacy of election choosing to use the full powers of their office, others appointed and taking a more measured approach. It’s a can of worms.

This piecemeal approach to Senate reform also raises regional issues. As it stands, the regional balance of the Senate is many years out of date. British Columbia, for example, is screwed by the current Senate make-up. As long as the Senate is a largely powerless chamber of sober second-thought, the inequity is troubling but not an outrage. But give the Senate the legitimacy of election and that changes, and under-represented regions such as BC will rightly cry foul if this isn't addressed.

That’s why Senate reform can’t be done piecemeal, as Harper is half-heartedly trying to do. Do the little things, such as elected Senators, and you take away the pressure to make the other, necessary changes, and you enshrine the regional inequities and other problems, and magnify them by giving the Senate legitimacy.

No, real and meaningful Senate reform means a constitutional amendment. It means the amending formula. It means sitting down with the provinces and negotiating regional representation, and elections, and term limits, and the balance of powers between House and Senate. It means lobbying for public support for that bill, and passing it through the provincial legislatures and the federal parliament.

And for those who say Harper needs to stack the Senate to pass legislation to reform it, I assure you: if such a constitutional amendment had the support of the people, the provinces and the Commons, the Senate would never stand in the way.

Harper, though, has no intention of even attempting the heavy-lifting necessary to truly reform the Senate. Having witnessed Meech and Charlottetown, I don’t necessarily blame him.

But if he isn’t willing to do what’s necessary then he should stop pretending he’s serious about Senate reform, and stop pretending his appointments this week were anything but what they were: an orgy of political cronyism in the best traditions of Canadian politics.

Because it was nothing to do with Senate reform.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Thursday, August 27, 2009

Fill in the Conservative hack

Sure, Stephen Harper said he believes Senators must be elected. And he does. He just didn't tell you he gets to write the ballot and cast the only votes...

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

That's not rain on my leg, Mr. Harper

So, according to the media buzz, Stephen Harper is about to once again stack the Senate with unelected, unaccountable Conservative cronies. The Liberals will decry his appointment of partisan hacks, the Conservatives will say they need their hacks to balance our hacks, and the public will say shut up I’m having dinner.

Such is how the political game has always been played, like some sort of kabuki play, only without the flashy costumes. So why should anyone care? Doesn’t everyone always do this? Well, there is one subtle difference: Harper promised us he was different.

Say what you will about my Liberals, but we never made any claims to righteous moral piety when it came to the Senate. Sure, we made an effort to appoint well-qualified non-hacks, such as General Romeo Dallaire. Paul Martin even appointed several Progressive Conservatives, including Hugh Segal, as well as an (independent) NDPer to the Senate. But we also appointed our hacks too, and we never pretended otherwise.

Not so Stephen Harper. Mr. Harper and his many of marry crusaders emerged from the Western plains atop gallant white steeds to lay claim to the mantal of moral righteousness and superiority, promising they would never stoop so low. Here’s just a sampling of his comments over the years:

"We don't support any Senate appointments."
(Stephen Harper, Winnipeg Free Press, January 29, 1996)

"Despite the fine work of many individual Senators, the Upper House remains a dumping ground for the favoured cronies of the Prime Minister."
(Stephen Harper Leadership Website, January 15, 2004)

"In the 21st century, those who want to sit in the parliament of a democratic state should have a mandate from the people."
(Stephen Harper, February 7, 2006)

"A conservative government will not appoint to the senate anyone who does not have a mandate from the people."
(Conservative Party website during 2006 election)

"As everyone in this room knows, it has become a right of passage for aspiring leaders and prime ministers to promise Senate reform - on their way to the top - but once they are elected, Senate reform quickly falls to the bottom of the Government's agenda. Nothing ever gets done."
(Stephen Harper, Speech on Senate Reform before Senate Committee, September 7, 2006)

"I don't plan to appoint senators; that's not my intention."
(Stephen Harper, Cornwall Standard-Freeholder, January 14, 2006)

"Stephen Harper will cease patronage appointments to the Senate. Only candidates elected by the people will be named to the Upper House."
(Stephen Harper Leadership Website, January 15, 2004)
If Harper hadn’t have made such a high-handed morally righteous crusade promising to be the white knight of Senate reform, then I wouldn’t really care that much. Sure, I’d slam him for appointing his hacks, but that’s just la guerre. It’s form. But by laying claim to such moral piety, by casting himself as the saint, when he gets down in the muck with the rest of us mere mortals he falls all the further.

In other words, Stephen Harper, don’t piss on my leg and tell me it’s raining.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Wednesday, December 24, 2008

Some Senate thoughts

While stacking the Senate with partisan hacks covered by one or two less odious picks is a long-held Prime Ministerial tradition in Canada, there are a few factors that allow me to take issue with the Harper 18 with something other than the usual partisan angst.

First, these appointments go against all the supposed principles and ideals that the Harper Conservatives and their Alliance/Reform predecessors supposedly stood for. The apologists will try to explain it away, pragmatism and all that, but if there are any true believers left in the Conservative camp they should be crying today. The face is, Harper is not serious about Senate reform. If he were, he’d have begun constitutional negotiations with the provinces. And as for the promise these Senators will resign to run elections if/when they’re held. That’s nice. But didn’t Harper promise not to appoint unelected Senators? So, yeah, things change, and I wouldn’t be surprised to see this promise be backed away from as well.

Still, just for fun, I’d love to see one of the provinces hold a Senate election, just for fun. How about PEI? Let’s get Mike Duffy on the campaign trail! And don’t worry Mike, we won’t show the outtakes of your campaign interview with ATV. Will Ontario elect Irving Gerstein, a Conservative bagman who has never been on a ballot. Will BC elect Yonah Martin or Newfoundland Fabian Manning, people they both rejected as MP candidates this fall? I don’t favour Senate elections without real constitutional reform to address regional imbalance, but this would almost make it worth it.

But back to these appointments, my second issue is the fact Harper lacks the moral legitimacy to make these appointments. He had to beg the Governor-General to prorogue parliament to avoid a confidence vote he was sure to lose. Even if the GG put no conditions on the prorogual, until Harper proves he has the confidence of the house in my view, while perfectly legal, it’s morally inappropriate for him to be stacking the Senate and stuffing Conservatives into every appointment he can find.

Finally, Harper has a minority government. As such, it would be appropriate for him to consult with the opposition parties on such major appointments. Again, it’s not a legal requirement, but is that the only standard we want to hold our politicians too? I thought Paul Martin set a very good example with how he handled Senate appointments as a minority Prime Minister, appointing a few Conservatives and even an (independent) NDPer to the Senate, as well as Liberals. An example Harper ignored.

Anyway, those objections aside, of course Harper is free to appoint whomever he wants. But, that said, is this really the best he can do?

I don’t care about Mike Duffy, the guy has been angling for an appointment for years. When the Liberals were in government, he sucked-up to them. I won’t lose any sleep over Duffy, and he’ll sleep well in the red chamber. Pamela Walin? It was the Liberals who appointed her a counsel-general, and besides, Harper owed her for providing him political cover with the Manley Afghanistan Commission (speaking of which, where’s Manley’s Senate seat?). Patrick Brazeau and Nancy Green Raine? Sure, why not.

But the others? Fabian Manning, a former Conservative MP just rejected by Newfoundland voters? A staffer in Rodney MacDonald’s office in Stephen Greene? Top CPC fundraiser Irving Gerstein, who ignored a summons to testify before a parliamentary committee in in-and-out? Another failed candidate from BC in Yonah Martin? And, of course, a separatist from Quebec in Michel Rivard, a guy who, as a Parti Quebecois MNA, actively campaigned to break-up Canada during the last referendum. I thought the whole reason Harper was pushing through these appointments was to stop separatists from being appointed to the Senate, not to appoint them himself?

I mean, if you’re going to toss out all your supposed moral principles about Senate reform and stack it with a bunch of Conservative hacks, couldn’t Harper have at least found a higher quality of Conservative hack? What, did Stephen Taylor and Kate MacMillan say no? Or do these picks really represent the crème de la crème of Conservative hackdom?

Or, maybe, there’s still some Conservatives out there that are willing to stand on principle and wanted nothing to do with this, even if their leader feels differently. They must be getting lonely though.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Sunday, December 21, 2008

I’ll huff, and I’ll puff, and I’ll blow this Senate down

From the hot air department:

If the Conservative government can't get its planned reforms to the Canadian Senate passed as soon as possible it will simply move to abolish the chamber altogether, says Steven Fletcher, the minister of state for democratic reform.
Yeah, I’m going to go ahead and call BS on that one.

I’ve argued before that the Conservative commitment to Senate reform has been truly half-asses at best, nibbling away around the edges in a way that will actually only create a worse situation: an elected Senate, unafraid of using its power, but with the regional inequities entrenched. The only real way to reform the Senate is through constitutional reform with the provinces. That’s a process the Conservatives have shown absolutely no appetite for.

Now, Stephen Fletcher is threatening to abolish the Senate if his nibbling, possibly unconstitutional “reforms” aren’t passed? Please. Does he think he can just abolish the Senate by fiat? Actually, given the understanding the Conservatives have demonstrated for our democratic process, maybe he does. But no, abolishing the Senate would require constitutional reform and amendment in negotiation with the provinces.

Do the Conservatives seriously expect us to believe they have the appetite for entering constitutional negotiations with the provinces to abolish the Senate when they have been unwilling to use this process to usher in the meaningful sort of Senate reform they CLAIM to stand for? Please.

Keep huffing and puffing, gentlemen.

And in the mean time, the Conservatives will demonstrate their commitment to Senate reform tomorrow by sending one of their top fundraisers to patronage heaven. Why, Reformers? Because the Liberals do it too. Preston must be so proud.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers