Showing posts with label The House. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The House. Show all posts

Thursday, May 30, 2013

There is an argument for the Senate – just not this Senate, or this House of Commons

The Senate has been much in the news lately, with the expense troubles of a few Senators – compounded by the mishandling of their investigation – bringing much  negative attention to the other place. While this is really a scandal about Stephen Harper’s decision-making and the style of governance he fosters, a serious and real national debate about the Senate’s place in our democracy is long overdue.

It’s easy to look at the shenanigans and say just abolish the thing. The NDP wasted little time in making that case. I think the misdoings of a few Senators is a poor argument for abolishing the thing. However, the NDP are long-standing abolitionists and, while I disagree for reasons I’ll outline shortly, I credit them for their consistency on the issue. Some of the provinces have also begun making pro-abolition musings. Some Conservatives too, although the official party position – in spite of their utter lack of substantive progress towards it – is to reform the Senate to be at least elected and effective; I’m not sure about the equal.

The Liberal position on the Senate has always been a bit more difficult to pin down, other than, of course, preferring we be the ones doing the appointing. From what I can gather, we’re lukewarm on elections, fine with term limits, and (rightly) believe real reform requires constitutional amendment – which we’re not keen on doing. The latter issue has been referred by the government to the Supreme Court for an opinion; I think the answer is fairly obvious, but we’ll see what they say. Stéphane Dion Dion has also done some interesting work in this area.

While abolition is an easy and populist argument to make, there is a case to be made for keeping the Senate. I don’t think I’ve heard it made yet, though.

I want us to keep the Senate. Just not this Senate. Let me make this clear: I’m arguing for a substantively reformed Senate, not the status quo. With respect to all the fine reports, hearings and second thought the upper chamber provides today, it’s not enough to justify its existence in its current form.

In any democracy with a bicameral system, the two houses are meant to each serve separate and distinct purposes. The lower chamber, our House of Commons, is meant to be the people’s house, pure representation by population. This would mean areas with more people get more seats, and more populous regions would have more representation. The purest form of democracy, but in a geographically diverse country with divergent regional interests, there’s potential for important perspectives not to be heard. Which is where the upper chamber – our Senate – is supposed to come in: as a body with representation equally allotted not by population but by region, providing a regional counterbalance to the rep by pop voice of the lower chamber.

Problem is, neither chambers fill those roles today. For the House of Commons, just look at the last round of seat redistribution. Instead of proportioning seats purely on population, politics meant faster growing regions remained somewhat under-represented, Quebec still had to be kept at a certain level, and seats were added because taking away seats from any area was deemed politically unacceptable.

And then there’s the Senate. With a formula based on how Canada looked closer to Confederation than today, the regional balance is out of whack. The Maritimes are over-represented; the West under-represented. It’s also unelected, which, frankly, is a positive right now because, without a regional rebalancing and a revision of the powers of the Senate – if we elected Senators today and gave them a democratic mandate, gridlock could ensue, and the West would be greatly disadvantaged. Without a democratic mandate today, Senators rightly exercise just a fraction of their constitutional authority.

I’d favour abolition over the status quo. Abolition would still, though, require a constitutional amendment and probably provincial negotiation. So before we decide between abolition and reform, the question we need to ask is, in an ideal world, do we want a true bicameral system, and is a regional check on the rep by pop power of the Commons desirable?

I think, in a country like Canada, that regional check is essential. The perspectives of the West, of Quebec, of the Maritimes, and of Ontario, are often unique and different. A properly-constituted Senate would ensure that, as laws are made and the future of our country charted, these perspectives are heard.

And if we’re going to be doing the constitutional thing anyway, I’d rather fix our democracy and get this thing right.  So, as part of such a process, here’s a few things I’d like to see:

  • An overhaul of representation in the House of Commons, including a reviewable cap on the number of MPs and the proportioning of seats purely on population, moving seats from declining-population areas to higher-population areas.
  • An elected Senate, with set terms and an end to the archaic constitutional requirements for a minimum age and land ownership. Also, rebalancing representation so Senate seats are allotted equally by region.
  • A revision of the powers and role of the Senate. It should be effective in reviewing and proposing legislation, and curbing the excesses of the House, but to avoid gridlock there should be a mechanism for the House to over-turn a Senate move to over-rule it if a certain threshold of support (say, two-thirds) can be achieved.

Getting to such a model may not be possible. It would require a great deal of negotiation among competing federal and provincial interests, not to mention Indigenous and municipal. There would need to be a great deal of give and take, and getting the balance right would be difficult. The temptation would be to widen the scope of the constitutional negotiation, which would be a mistake – history shows focus in these things is important.

Let’s remember though, abolition would also be difficult. It’s not as easy as waving a magic wand. Provincial support (and likely a referendum) would also be required for an abolition constitutional amendment, and the same competing interests would need to be satisfied.

If we’re increasingly agreed though that blithely accepting the status quo because change is difficult is no longer acceptable, then change becomes inevitable. The only question is, what change. It’s time we had a national debate about what that change should be.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Will anyone stand-up for equality of parliamentary representation?

With our parliamentarians having returned to Ottawa this week, it seems appropriate to turn our attention to just how our parliament is composed. Representation in the House of Commons is sure to be a contentious issue once again, and I’m having a hard time finding a sensible position from any of the parties.

I won’t rehash all the background – long story short, representation in the lower house is supposed to be by population, but population shifts across the country over the years mean the current house isn’t truly representative of today’s Canada. Suburban/urban areas in British Columbia, Alberta are extremely under-represented.

The Conservatives have had a proposal on the table for several years to add 30 seats (five in Alberta, seven in B.C. and 18 in Ontario) that would make some progress toward more representative representation. It has gone through some modifications following complaints from various quarters, and they haven’t been in much of a hurry to move forward with it. Indeed, they seemed to agree with the other parties in the last parliament to quietly shelve it until after the election – none of them wanted the issue floating around during a campaign.

Why? That’s the heart of the issue: it’s all about Quebec. Any other province would accept their population doesn’t warrant more seats but, for Quebec, it’s a “national unity” issue. With other regions growing, they see their influence in the House of Common declining. And they’re demanding artificial measures (extra seats not warranted by population) in recognition of their “special” status. The most common ask: a guaranteed floor of 25 per cent of HoC seats, regardless of population.

It’s called the Senate

I strongly disagree with this. Representation in the House of Commons should be by population, period. Giving one region unequal weighting would mean taking representation from another region; that’s unfair and that’s not the purpose of the lower chamber.

Do I agree that Quebec has a unique perspective? Yes. And I believe the Maritimes, Ontario, Western Canada and British Columbia do too. And the territories. And I believe having a regional bulkwark to a pure rep by pop system that gives Ontario a very large voice is important and desirable.

And we already have a body designed to provide (in theory) that regional check: It’s called the Senate. The lower house is intended as the representative house; the upper the regional check.

Now the Senate is in need of reform and redistribution as well. But if you want to build a truly effective and representative parliamentary democracy, gerrymandering commons representation isn’t the answer. Reform the Senate so it is fairly distributed along regional lines, with elected Senators who have a clear mandate and set of powers and responsibilities.

About those Commons seats

Now, I won’t hold my breath for any of the political parties to start advocating comprehensive and meaningful Senate reform. And sorry, what the Conservatives have been doing here has been hurting, not helping.

I’d be more hopeful of someone taking a logical position on Commons representation though. Sadly, no such luck so far.

There’s some hope in the Conservative position. It could go further, but it’s a step in the right direction. While they’ve disavowed special considerations for Quebec, as mentioned they’ve shown no hurry to move forward with actual legislation either.

My Liberals have been hard to pin down. Before the election they helped to delay the proposal, and splits were evident between their Quebec caucus and the rest of the members. After the election? Interim leader Bob Rae gave an interview that left me puzzled.

(Rae) predicted that the prime minister will come up with a compromise on the seat legislation bill to deal with Quebec's concerns.

"I don't think you can take Quebec for granted, and I think the prime minister's going to have to look again at the question of the number of Quebec seats. It doesn't mean B.C., Alberta and Ontario won't get more seats - of course we will."

OK, so he wants special dispensation for Quebec?

Rae wouldn't say whether or not he supports the position of many Quebec nationalists that the province should be guaranteed 25 per cent of the seats.

So compromise if necessary, but not necessarily that compromise? OK, but what then? After all, this is about national unity, somehow.

With their new large Quebec caucus, the NDP has been a little more clear on its position: special seats for Quebec.

(Brian Topp) giving extra seats to Quebec would be a way to recognize its status as a nation within Canada.

"I think we need to find an appropriate Canadian compromise," he said at a news conference announcing his candidacy.

And the guy that may not run:

The NDP has argued that Quebec should be guaranteed to maintain its current share of the seats. That would require the 338-seat Commons to be swollen further by boosting Quebec's allotment to 82 or 83 seats, from the current 75.

Earlier Monday, Mulcair told reporters that such a move is consistent with the 2006 "nation" motion and the 1991 Supreme Court of Canada decision.

"It would be an irony to say that Quebec constitutes — the Quebecois constitute — a nation within Canada and then the first thing you do is you reduce the . . . weight of Quebecers within the House of Commons."

Nation reflux disease

There is a certain irony that many of the arguments being made come back to the Quebec nation resolution of 2006, hailed at the time as a master-stroke of strategic genius by Prime Minister Harper. My worry then was that you can say it’s just symbolism, but empty symbolism isn’t going to satisfy anyone; eventually they’ll want something real. Now those chickens are coming home to roost: the Quebec nationalists want some meat on that nation bone we gave them. The question is what happens if they don’t get it?

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Sunday, January 10, 2010

The demographics around the anti-prorogation anger

In an interview with Kathleen Petty yesterday on CBC Radio's The House, pollster Frank Graves of Ekos Research made some interesting points about what his research is showing him about the growing discontent with the Stephen Harper Conservatives around the decision to shutter parliament for two months. The short of it: it's not just the usual suspects that are annoyed, and it goes deeper that the prorogation.

Here's a transcript. Emphasis is mine:

KATHLEEN PETTY (HOST):
Well apparently, Michael Ignatieff is not alone; In a national poll released by the firm EKOS, two thirds of respondents didn't think the move was crazy, necessarily, but they did know the Prime Minister shut down Parliament, and of those, nearly 60 percent were opposed to the prorogation. Frank Graves is the president of EKOS; he joins me in the studio. Good morning, welcome to "The House."

FRANK GRAVES (PRESIDENT, EKOS RESEARCH ASSOCIATES):
Good to be here.

PETTY:
So, is it the number or is it the demographic behind that number that really tells the story, here?

GRAVES:
Well, I think they're both interesting, but perhaps a more interesting thing, which hasn't really been discussed at this point, is the demographic. There's another very interesting feature to the demographic, but I think the most striking one is the... how much this issue has caught the attention of the most educated portions of the electorate and the "baby boom" cohort, which as we know, has been an extremely influential and large portion of the electorate, ones that all show up to vote, ones who have an inordinate level of influence. You could argue that this particular group has exerted almost a stranglehold over the political system for a long time. This group has been pretty solidly onside with Mr. Harper for some time, now. They came onside in the last election and were one of the keys to this success which almost propelled him to a majority victory. So, the fact that they're now having second thoughts about this particular issue... I think this particular issue has become a bit of lightning rod which is capturing a broader sense of disaffection on a number of other issues which have occurred previous to it, but it is something that probably signals greater importance as time goes on, or it could potentially do that.

PETTY:
It also speaks to whether it can be sustained, it seems to me. Because if you're talking about people who are influential and who are opinion leaders, then the ability to sustain a dissatisfaction or unhappiness with prorogation... it seems to me that the likelihood is higher in that case.

GRAVES:
Absolutely, and I think just to add further credibility to that thesis, it's my sense that we've seen a bit of a turnaround in some of the elite intelligentsia coverage of Mr. Harper, which has moved from this very fawning applause that we saw concurrent with the NAC performance - which also, coincidentally, coincided with him moving into majority territory, he was around 42 points, then. Today, he's around 33 points, but it does seem that there's now... We have front page editorials from the Globe and Mail, we have him pilloried by The Economist -

PETTY:
And we've got a trend, and that's the other interesting part. You talk about the NAC performance, but as you take a look at your polling over a period of time, the gap between the Tories and the Liberals used to be wide.

GRAVES:
Almost insurmountable; You had a daunting 15-point lead which was understating the Conservative edge, because the Conservatives have a much more committed voter base, so in fact, when they were running 41-42 points, our calculations are that they would have produced a very decisive majority in the neighbourhood of 180 seats at that point. Today, these numbers would suggest that they're at least as close, probably... no they are closer to actually sitting on the wrong side of the House than they are to that goal of forming a majority.

PETTY:
But these numbers aren't just because of prorogation; it's a cumulative effect to which prorogation has sort of added an extra push, in your view.

GRAVES:
Yeah, but it seems to me that now, this latest issue shouldn't be judged just in terms of, "are people really that upset about prorogation?", or has it become something which captures a broader critical mass of concerns about -

PETTY:
Emblematic.

GRAVES:
Yes, and you're quite right. The decline that we'd seen in sort of... "propeller head" terminology was a monotonic progressive straight-line decline. It was up here or... it wasn't oscillating up and down, it was on a very well- behaved statistical pattern. It seemed to have stopped when Parliament recessed, and this newest episode... remember, over the Christmas period, there's really. .. nothing else happened that would explain why we saw a further three-point drop, which in our samples, which are very large, was highly statistically and substantially significant. So, the only thing that plausibly explains it, and when you link it back as well to concerns about this and look where the attrition occurred, it was this same group that we were talking about before, the "boomers", the educated, and so forth, who seemed to have had some serious second thoughts. That may not be permanent, but it's something which is perhaps more important than the usual sort of three-point fluctuations that you might see on a day-to-day basis.

PETTY:
Okay, well you've given us stuff to watch for, and we will watch for it. Frank, thanks very much.

GRAVES:
Okay, my pleasure.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers