Showing posts with label Childcare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Childcare. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 03, 2010

Thinking about: Early Learning and Childcare

I’m back from a week and a bit back in B.C. visiting family and what not, and have ended my temporary blogging prorogation. It’s good to take a break every once and awhile to recharge the blogging batteries. I certainly picked a busy time to prorogue too, with a bevy of on-target Liberal policy stories, some very positive polls, some interesting legal developments, and more channel-change attempts from Conservaland than you can shake a stick at.

It will take a little while to get caught-up and offer some perspective in what I’d say was a very good week for the Liberals, but I did first want to talk about Michael Ignatieff’s comments Monday on Early Learning and Childcare.

Michael Ignatieff won't let the biggest deficit in Canadian history stop him from promising that a Liberal government would make major investments in child care.

The Liberal Leader told reporters yesterday that there is no better way to increase productivity, social justice and equality across the country than by putting money into programs that give children a head start.

Mr. Ignatieff would not put a price tag on the kind of child-care program he envisions, saying that it would depend on the financial situation at the time his party took power.

But, he said, “we will find the money because it seems to me to be an excellent investment.

“[The Conservatives] are saying you can't invest in anything that makes this a fairer country because we have a $56-billion deficit,” Mr. Ignatieff said. “Well, who created it in the first place? I am not going to allow the deficit discussion to shut down the discussion in this country about social justice.”

As the Toronto Star notes, we need both details about the program proposed and pricing information, and I trust both will be forthcoming before we’re into an election campaign. But this is a welcome commitment from Ignatieff for a number of reasons: it reclaims strong Liberal ground, positions Ignatieff to the left of centre countering the traditional narrative on him, and it draws sharp contrasts between the Liberal and Conservatives on an important policy question.

Before getting into the substantive “why” of why a strong commitment to early learning and childcare is important, let’s dispense with the criticisms and the political angles.

The Politics

Sure, the Liberals have long been talking about early learning and childcare, and have been slow to deliver. Fair enough. Let’s not forget though that, before the opposition parties pulled the plug, Paul Martin and Ken Dryden were delivering. The last Liberal government had signed child care agreements with the majority of the provinces that saw hundreds of millions of dollars flow in long-term agreements that created thousands of spaces. The reverberations of the Conservatives allowing those agreements to expire are now being felt across the country, as most of those spaces disappear from a system already short of capacity.

We need to acknowledge our historical failings, but also talk about the impressive progress we have made on this file that these critics decide to ignore, and how we can, and will, do better, and do more. And even if some people are skeptical of our commitment, frankly, why should that deter us? It’s the right thing to do, and that’s enough. Let them doubt us, make the commitment and then, if we get the chance, follow through.

That’s from the left. On the right, the Conservatives will complain of a) the cost, and b) restricting choice. First of all, with few details available on the Liberal plan, to say (as Ryan Sparrow did) that it would restrict parental choices is pure speculation, if not outright fiction.

Indeed, since the Liberals say they won’t kill the Conservatives’ laughable (and taxable) $100 monthly child care cheques, the Liberal program would seem to be adding choice, not restricting it. And with the Conservatives having failed to even come close to creating the spaces they'd promised (actually, we're now further behind) thanks to Stephen Harper parents have less and less choice every day.

On price, mes amis over at the National Post raise an interesting objection:
Mr. Ignatieff hasn't indicated whether he intends his program to cover every family in Canada, regardless of income. If the Liberal leader does intend the plan to be universal, then he's peddling a bad idea: Most of the children who take part likely will not benefit in any statistically appreciable way, and the program will simply amount to a multi-billion dollar transfer payment from government to parents.
Makes me wonder if the Post editors would support a program for low-income families only were that proposed? I suspect they’d find objections too, complaining of all the middle-class families left out. But some people need something to be opposed to.

But assuming it is a universal program (which I’m inclined to favour) let me reframe the question: why would the Conservatives and the Post not favour what is akin to a targeted major tax cut to working Canadian families?

Because that, in essence, is what we’d be talking about. For many Canadian families, child care is a major expense. A government program would sharply reduce or even reduce that expense, potentially leaving families with hundreds of extra dollars in their pockets. The Conservatives are all about targeted tax relief. So change the framing: why would the Conservatives oppose saving Canadian families thousands of dollars a year?

And on the larger issue of balancing the cost of investment versus the budget situation, frankly, that’s going to be a consideration with any policy proposal of import by any party. And certainty the Conservatives have no credible claim to budgetary responsibility. Yes, prudence will be needed and choices will have to be made. But investment cannot stop and, if we’re setting priorities, I’d stack early learning and child care up against Conservative priorities any day of the week, and I think Canadians will too. Some things will always be important, and this is one.

The Policy

To segue more over to the policy side, there are strong arguments to be made for investments on early learning and childcare paying dividends to the treasury anyways. For those families unable to afford childcare today, a program will allow them to return to work, or work more, contributing more to the economy (and generating more tax revenue for the government.) For those parents already working, the money saved can be invested in other areas that can also create economic opportunity and generate tax revenue.

That’s short-term. Longer-term, as I talked about in my Thinking about: Education piece, a healthy and educated person gets a better job, lives longer, creates more economic opportunity and generates more tax revenue for the government. There’s no doubt that investments in education and in early childhood learning are returned in surplus. And it’s important to begin with early childhood learning: a child that gets a good start and gains a love of learning early will have greater success as they make their way through the education system, and have a greater chance of success in life.

Lastly, let me say that as the details of the Liberal proposal are decided, keeping an element of parental choice, and prominently acknowledging the importance of choice, is important. The system should be flexible, and that has been a failing of past Liberal proposals. I don’t propose a payment for opting-out, I wouldn’t go beyond leaving the $100/month cheque program in place there. Flexibility otherwise is important though.

Anyway, as I said more details must be forthcoming, but I like the positioning and the messaging from Ignatieff here.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Tuesday, January 05, 2010

Thinking about: Education

We bloggers are usually quite good at identifying the problems, myself included. That’s easy enough to do. I’ve long kvetched about the Liberal Party’s focus on the tactical and the scandal while ignoring the strategic, the policy, the vision thing. Over the next little while, in the lead-up to the much hyped Thinker’s Thingamajig, I’m going to try offering some suggestions on that front.

First up in this series, I’d like to mention education. Long-time readers will know education is an issue I’ve long been concerned about and have long been writing about. And I continue to believe education is a fundamentally core issue that is critical to the success and future health and prosperity of our country, and is of great importance to Canadians. It’s an issue area in which the Liberal Party must absolutely claim a visionary, forward-thinking leadership role.

Perhaps uniquely, education plays across so many other issue areas. Want a strong, competitive economy? You need an educated workforce. Want to fight child poverty? Education goes a long way to lifting families out of poverty. Improved health care? You need more trained doctors, nurses, technicians. Improved standard of living? Compete internationally? New jobs and industries? Going green? Education underpins it all.

And education is only becoming more important in the 21st century. We can’t compete with emerging economies on the price of our labour. We have to compete with our brains, and yet we’re falling behind the world. Companies such as Cisco Systems are opening facilities and moving jobs to place such as India not for labour cost, but for skilled workers. China and India and other emerging economic powerhouses are investing in their education systems, and it is paying results. Jobs will go where the brains are, and with the jobs go economic prosperity.

We need to make it easier for Canadians to attend post-secondary education, be it university, college or skilled trades. Not harder. And we should ensure that we no longer burden them with crippling, life-long debt loads in the process. We need to increase government investment in post-secondary education, and we need to begin to look at it not as a cost centre, but as an investment.

Because that’s what it is. A more educated Canadian will find a better job, earn a better salary, and pay higher taxes to the government. They may even create their own business, paying business taxes and creating jobs for other taxpaying Canadians. They’re also less likely to be a drain on government services. In short, our investment in the education of our citizens will pay great dividends. We get back our investment many times.

Let’s be bold. Why can’t we explore free undergrad or college tuition for every Canadian? Or a lifetime entitlement for XX hours of skill training for every Canadian? If not, we should at least consider it for certain targeted professions and skills that are highly in demand.

At the very least, we need to throw out a student loan system that is fundamentally flawed and build something that works. It's become a commercial money-making venture for banks. That's wrong. Far better would be interest-free loans or, better yet, do away with loans all together for a system of bursaries.

We need to work with the provinces, who have constitutional responsibility for education, to rethink the system and ensure that national standards are maintained and that any funding increases do filter down to the universities students and aren’t eaten up by the provinces. And colleges and trades training must absolutely be a critical part of the discussion.

It goes wider than just this though. Too many immigrants come to Canada with skills we need but aren’t able to get work in their fields. Foreign credential recognition has long been a swampy topic. The Conservative government recently made some progress on this topic. We need to build and expand on that.

And education also needs to begin, well, at the beginning, with early learning and childcare. Studies show children that set out on the right path early develop a life-long love of learning, and will go on to greater success and prosperity in their lives.

After many years, the previous Liberal government under Paul Martin, thanks to the hard work of Ken Dryden, had finally made a good start on this front, negotiating long-term agreements with many of the provinces. Unfortunately, that work has been abandoned by the current government in favour of a flawed tax-credit system. With the Liberal funding agreements now ending we’re seeing just how flawed: precious child care spaces are disappearing.

We need to pick up that squandered momentum and make early childhood learning and childcare a priority once again. But we can’t stop there. We need to acknowledge that what we had proposed earlier was incomplete. Flexibility, and options for those who wish to stay at home to care for their children, or have a family member do so, must be built into the system. Choice is crucial.

Finally, it’s all well and good to have high-minded discussion about the importance of education in broad strokes. We also need to bring it down to the ground and make it understandable and saleable. We’ve always been good at the idealism in the past, but the Conservatives have kicked our asses on the realism, on the distilling it into something people can relate to.

We need a package of proposals and initiatives that will not only make the systemic reforms we need, but will have an impact in the daily lives of Canadians: such as XX lifetime hours of free skill training, or free tuition, and so on. Make it relatable and understandable if it’s going to be successful.

Otherwise, it really will just be an academic gabfest, and we don’t need one of those.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Paul Martin: Invest in early childhood learning now

Former Prime Minister Paul Martin spoke this week at a conference on early childhood development in New Brunswick, where he made a strong pitch that now is the time to invest in this important area:

"Governments are going to tell you that early learning is something they simply cannot afford at this time. When they do, I might suggest you'd like to reply as follows," Martin advised.

"First, early childhood development should be an essential part of any economic stimulus package," he said to raucous applause. "More than anything else, it's the gift that keeps giving."

He compared today's situation to 1945, "when governments were broke because of World War II."

"They also feared a return to the depression of the 1930's," he said. "So they began to invest in the social infrastructure we have today -- better health care, better pensions, better education -- and the confidence this gave Canadians set Canada on the longest unbroken period of prosperity we have ever known in our history."

Saying the US economy will continue to grow in the future, but will "no longer be alone as the engine of growth," Martin said it will be joined by countries like China, India and Brazil and an expanding Europe, regions with whom Canada does not share an economically beneficial border.

"The world is about to get a heck of a lot more competitive," the long-time federal finance minister noted, saying in a world where China graduates more engineers each year than are working in all of Canada, an educated populace is crucial to maintaining prosperity.

"We are not going to compete with countries with populations approaching one billion on the basis of the number of people we have. We're going to compete with them on the basis of skill and innovation."

That's why early learning is the pathway to the future, Martin said. "We cannot afford to waste the talent of even one young Canadian."

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Friday, November 09, 2007

Governing is about choices...let’s give them choice

If you polled 1000 Canadians, I bet you, say, 80 per cent of them would say they like cake, and they’d love it if the government enrolled them gratis in the cake of the month club. Starting with angel food in January, all the way through to ice cream cake (my fave, the one from DQ with the chocolate fudge crackle) in December. Because, except for those that perhaps can’t eat sugar, everyone loves cake. And, even better, what tastes sweeter than free cake?

That’s why the results of this particular poll are wholly unsurprising to me (h/t Steve):

The Canadian Press Harris-Decima poll – conducted in the three days after the Halloween economic update – found that 83 per cent of Canadians surveyed said they supported the income tax cuts.

Seventy-six per cent approved of reducing the GST by one percentage point.

So, Canadians would, by and large, not say no to a tax cut. And they’d like a free cake too.

What would happen, however, if you introduced choice? Because our free cake program would cost money. We’d need to buy the cakes, for one, although by buying in bulk we could probably get a deal, maybe from some super bakery in China. We’d need some bureaucrats to run the program, a department of baked goods if you will. Maybe even a cake registry so we can track the cakes to make sure no one gets extra cakes, and ensure everyone gets their just deserts. The lessons learned on the gun registry will come in handy – don’t worry, we’ll get it right this time, no billion-dollar flans.

So, to pay for our cakes for the masses program we’re going to need to trim somewhere else in the budget. Luckily though, we have a surplus at the moment, so no budget cuts needed. We could do something else with the surplus though than buying everyone cake. Like, say, universal daycare, and a cupcake per month for every child under six.

Ask Canadians if they’d like free cake they’re going to say yes. Give them a choice between free cake and universal daycare and a cupcake for their kid (with the option of two cupcakes and a juice box if the parent chooses to stay at home or enlists grandma to babysit) and the result will be very different.

The key, though, is to give people that choice, and that’s what we Liberals have been doing a bad job of. Harper is out there offering everyone free cake, and we’re just saying cake bad, no cake for you! Of course people are going to respond poorly to that. I would too. Tocuhe pas my cake Stephane!

We need to offer Canadians a choice. Cake looks good in isolation. But, when brought into context and contrasted with, say, a major push to eliminate child poverty, cake, or tax cuts, cake is viewed in a whole other light. When contrasted against such a choice, be it a real, flexible (meaning some kind of consideration for parents to opt-out and home care) daycare, or fighting child poverty, Harper’s GST cut is more easily seen for what it is: a cynical, selfish vote buying measure that 101 economists agree makes piss poor economic sense.

That’s why I’m cautiously optimistic to read this (again H/T to Steve):

Stephane Dion is poised to unveil a central plank in the Liberal election platform — a "bold" plan to reduce poverty in Canada.

An insider close to Dion said the Liberal leader will set ``aggressive but realistic" multi-year targets for reducing poverty in general and child poverty in particular.

He will also outline the policy tools a Liberal government would use – bolstering existing income support programs and new investments in things like child care and education – to meet those targets.

If this is true, if we are going to come out with some real, comprehensive and bold policy then it’s about bloody time, says I. Because it’s time we started defining ourselves as something other than merely just opposed to the Harper agenda. And it’s time we started illustrating the stark contrasts between Liberal and Conservative philosophies. And it’s time we started offering Canadians choice.

An income tax cut and a per cent off the GST, or an income tax cut and a major initiative to tackle child poverty? I know the side of that debate I’d like to be on. I’ll bring my own cake to the party.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers