Showing posts with label Gerry Nicholls. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gerry Nicholls. Show all posts

Friday, April 03, 2009

Is Harper's Conservative coalition falling apart?

While Stephen Harper has managed to hold it together until now by sheer force of his captivating personality, rigidly-enforced party discipline, and a collective lust for power, there is increasing evidence that after two minorities and no prospect for improvement, the fractious Conservative coalition is beginning to crumble.

Take two new Web sites launched recently designed to lobby the Conservative government. Cut The Fat.ca and No Bailouts.ca were launched under the auspices of the Canadian Taxpayer's Federation, a group that has traditionally been quite supportive of the Conservative Party, and can count a great many Conservatives as its members. Both are petition-sites, and make clear they're not pleased at all with the fiscal policies of the Harper government, even if they never use the words Conservative or Harper.

And interestingly, the apparent creative force behind the campaign, and the admin of the corresponding Facebook groups, is none other that Blogging Tory-poo bah and well-connected Conservative Stephen Taylor.

What does it say when staunch Conservative supporters need to launch Web sites to lobby their own government?

Also killing virtual trees is another new Web site called Homeless Cons: Conservatives in search of shelter. The group's mission?

Greetings. You are invited to join our network to meet like-minded HomelessCons and stop feeling like you're completely alone. Because the truth is, you're not. A lot of us are out there looking for shelter. Why not start building one?
Reading through some of the messages the members seem particularly disturbed by Harper's abandonment of supposed socially-conservative principles. Founder John Robson talks about the group:
"If you are a conservative in this country," Robson says over the phone, "you believe in free markets, traditional social values and strong national defence. You are lucky if you get one out of three out of any Conservative Party you elect."

And Robson thinks that with the way the Harper Conservatives are acting right now, the score is zero for three. The government will not touch the abortion issue he notes, gave up on the vote they promised on gay marriage and in his mind doesn't fund the troops properly. The final straw for Robson appears to have been the latest budget with its projection of a $64,000,000,000 deficit over two years; this after the government was already the biggest spending government in Canadian history. "If that's conservatism," he says, "why not vote Liberal."

So what do Conservative Party members and supporters think about the group? The regular reply seems to be, "Where are they going to go? They can't vote Liberal." That's true, but they could either stay home or start another party.

Take a look through the membership list and you'll recognize a good many prominent Blogging Tories, as well as such familiar names as Gerry Nichols, a former Conservative-loyalist (and Harper subordinate at the National Citizens Coalition) who has been on his own crusade (and book tour) of late lamenting how Harper has strayed from the path.

Some Conservative MPs are even unloading their souls to their Liberal colleagues, and asking the Liberals to provide the opposition that, as trained Conservative backbench seals, they're unable or unwilling to. Writes Liberal MP Glen Pearson:
Then a strange request: Would I be willing to be more aggressive in the House concerning the cuts, seeking at least a time of reappraisal of the results of such a decision. Let me get this straight: a member of the government was asking me to be more forceful in opposition? Indeed, we are living in strange times.

He said he would try within his own party to seek a second look at the CIDA change and I truly believe he will. But this is a Conservative government that doesn’t broker self-criticism. His task is hopeless, and I could tell he knew it just by the tone of his voice. Thus, his call to me.
Also interesting has been following the campaign by the Harper PMO to distance the party from former PM Brian Mulroney. There was a time when the PMO's word was scripture, but it seems more and more Conservative MPs, and even cabinet ministers, are willing to defy Harper and deviate from the PMO line:
On Tuesday, senior party sources told reporters that Mulroney was no longer a member of the Conservative Party of Canada. But Defence Minister Peter MacKay and Revenue Minister Jean-Pierre Blackburn say there must be a mistake because Mulroney will be a member for life.

And of course there was the recent Conservative in-fighting over their disastrous performance in Quebec last election.

The Sun's Greg Weston is even writing of the post-Harper era, which more and more Conservatives see as not that far away. The jockeying for Harper's job has begun:
Three times in recent weeks, for no apparent reason, we have been pleasantly entertained by senior Conservatives who, one suspects, would otherwise wish us no ill that wasn't slow, painful and terminal.

This suggests that either spring delirium has come early to the nation's capital, or Stephen Harper's party of the bound and gagged is starting to break loose for reasons worth risking the boss's wrath.

Buzz is starting in the backrooms and chatrooms that Conservatives looking down the road are seeing the next election and life after Harper coming sooner rather than later.
And all the king's horse's, and all the king's men...

___
**Help send a BCer to BC for the Liberal convention. Donations are tax deductible. Any support is greatly appreciated.

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Tuesday, February 03, 2009

On ideologues and revolutionaries, conservative and communist

The news pages have been replete with conservatives moaning and bemoaning the budget of Stephen Harper’s Conservatives. So angry are the true believers they’ve used the absolute worst adjective in their vocabularies to describe the Harper budget: Liberal. Ouch.

As I read the latest columns from disillusioned conservatives over lunch, this time by Gerry Nicholls in the Ottawa Citizen and Tasha Kheiriddin in the National Post, I was reminded of the fall of communism. No, really, hear me out.

In their columns, Nicholls and Kheiriddin, true-believers both, decry the fact that Harper the man who was supposed to be their conservative white night, a fellow ideologue, has, in power, strayed from the path to righteousness and has failed to deliver their promised conservative revolution. I knew Ronnie Reagan and you sir, they complain, are no Ronald Reagan.

Writes Nicholls:

But minority or no minority, Mr. Harper could have at least used his position as prime minister to extol and promote the virtues of smaller government and freer markets. But he never did.

Why? Because Mr. Harper and his strategists believe the only way for Conservatives to win elections is to act and talk like Liberals. Or to put it another way, the prime minister was willing to sacrifice his principles for the sake of political expediency.

This is an oft-repeated statement – that he feels he has to act less conservative to get a majority and then be free to act all conservative -- and its an interesting one to me.

What does it say of conservatism if a party cannot run openly and honestly on a conservative platform and then get a majority mandate to implement it? What does it say that they need to either hide their conservative tendencies or shed them, depending on which conspiracy theory you subscribe to, to get elected (and only then with a minority)? And what does it say that, in a time of fiscal crisis, a supposed conservative ideologue turns to deficit-funded stimulus spending instead of employing the conservative economic principles he wrote his thesis on?

Now, Nicholls and Kheiriddin will tell you Harper’s budget wasn’t an acknowledgment that conservative economics don’t work (although there’s a healthy body of evidence to show they don’t), but rather was merely a minority government forced by political and public opinion to open the Keynesian taps. Maybe so. It’s telling though that the conservatives (small c) can’t persuasively make the case for their own deeply-held views as the prescription for our economic ills. For believers in a market economy, they seem unwilling to accept that the public just ain’t buying what they’re selling. Which, it would seem to hold, would mean it doesn’t have worth.

Looking more widely though, while conservatism may sell from time to time in the U.S., in Canada it seems to be a consistent, and increasing non-starter. Which is how I got to thinking about the failure of the communist system.

Ask any old, battle worn, communist ideologue and they’ll tell you communism never failed, despite the historical record, because a) the true system as envisioned by Marx has never been properly implemented, as personal agendas and vanity have interceded, and b) it can’t be properly implemented until the entire world is under a communist utopia. Until that day, resources will always have to be diverted to things like defense, leading to a prevision of the system. It gives them an easy out (in their minds at least) to never have to really examine the failures of their ideology.

Similarly, I suspect ideological conservatives will always be able to find rationalizations and explanations for why small-c conservatism isn’t a failure, and why their ideology isn’t faulty, or at fault. It’s Stephen Harper’s fault for hewing toward centre in the name of pragmatism. It’s the Liberals’ fault for insisting on stimulus spending. It’s Canadians’ fault for not giving them a majority.

At what point do they ask themselves: is it the customer, or is it what they’re selling?

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Rivers in Egypt

Gerry Nicholls, whom may or may not have been ousted from his post with the right-wing National Citizens Coalition for badmouthing Deceivin’ Steven, attempts to diagnose Conservative troubles with a column in the Windsor Star today.

And while he makes some good points, he also falls into the same tired excuses used by so many Conservative apologists when expressing their disappointment with the Harper government.

Gerry’s thesis is that Harper is in danger of losing his base because he’s flip-flopping more than a fish out of water and is wildly trying to latch onto any policy idea he thinks will win him votes in his majority quest:

How are the Tories angering their base?

Well, take your pick.


There's the Tory flip-flop on income trusts, the pandering to Quebec nationalists, the

"Liberal-Lite" big spending budget or the Green Plan with its ridiculous light bulb ban.


All these actions represent a backtracking on conservative principles and values and all these actions have angered grassroots Conservatives


And simply put, that's just plain dumb.
I’ll agree with Gerry on a few things. On Harper being dumb (or rather acting dumb) I’m onboard. Dido the flip-flopping and the pandering. I’m not sure how environmentally-friendly light bulbs are a betrayal of Conservative values (ed: maybe they’re same-sex light bulbs?) but whatever.

Here’s where Gerry and I part ways though:
The Conservatives, in other words, have decided to act like Liberals.

And I guess it's a good plan except for one teensy-weensy problem: It isn't working.
This is a common refrain heard from dissatisfied Conservatives like Gerry, and it’s crap. It illustrates head in the sand thinking that conveniently allows them to skip over any needed self-introspection to address their problems.

The fact is Deceivin’ Steven’s Cons aren’t acting like Liberals. Maybe if they were they wouldn’t be free-falling in the polls.

But Liberals don’t cut funding to the Status of Women or kill the Court Challenges program. Liberals don’t bully province and invite them to sue. Liberals don’t raise income taxes. Liberals don’t run relentlessly negative attack ads outside of elections. Liberals don’t attack the families of political leaders, or question their loyalty to Canada. Or make fun of their ethnicity, or their accents.

Sorry Gerry, but Harper isn’t acting like a Liberal. He’s acting like a jerk. Is the problem really that Harper is acting “too Liberal” Gerry, or is it that most Canadians just aren’t buying what he’s selling?

Incidentally, even if Harper is doing a poor job of "acting like a Liberal" doesn't the fact he feels obligated to even try say something about the appeal of Conservatism in Canada?

Recommend this Post on Progressive Bloggers